In a study about phobias, researchers have identified two problems.
- (a)One problem is that they cannot be sure that they are studying phobias rather than just dislikes. For example, people may refuse to eat a food they claimed to have a phobia of simply because they don't like it. Explain whether this is a problem of validity or reliability. Validity or reliability: Explanation:[1]
- (b)Another problem is that they cannot be sure that they are measuring phobias consistently. For example, the researchers may interpret the participants' written comments differently. Explain whether this is a problem of validity or reliability. Validity or reliability: Explanation:[1]
Mark scheme
Marking points from the official mark scheme (Oct/Nov 2020). The mark or mark type is shown in brackets.
- [1] (a) 1 mark for name of validity and an explanation (does not have to be linked) Validity (identification) as they will not be measuring the variable they expected to measure (generic) = 1 Validity (identification) as they will not be measuring phobias, but dislikes instead (linked) = 1 Reliability (incorrect) as they will not be measuring phobias, but dislikes instead (linked) = 0
- [1] (b) 1 mark for name of reliability and an explanation (does not have to be linked) Reliability (identification) because it is about the researchers' consistency in recording data (explanation) (generic) = 1 Reliability (identification) because they may make different records from the same data (explanation) (linked) = 1 Validity (incorrect) because it is about the researchers' consistency in recording data (explanation) = 0
Write your answer and get it marked
On Oracle Prep you can write or photograph your own answer and have it marked by AI against this mark scheme, with feedback on what you missed.
Sign up free →