Dr Bahl wants to know about the emotions of people who spend their leisure time in different ways. He intends to use a questionnaire to collect information from these different types of people, about their emotions.
- (a)Explain one way that Dr Bahl could ensure that he obtains a varied sample of participants.[3]
- (b)Suggest one open question that Dr Bahl could ask about emotions.[1]
- (c)Explain one disadvantage of using open questions about emotion in this study.[2]
- (d)(i)Suggest one advantage of using an fMRI scanner to investigate emotions.[2]
- (d)(ii)Suggest one disadvantage of using an fMRI scanner to investigate emotions.[2]
Mark scheme
Marking points from the official mark scheme (May/June 2019). The mark or mark type is shown in brackets.
- [3] 1 mark for identify a representative sampling technique
- 2 marks for describing how the technique works/ produces a varied sample.
- To earn all 3 marks, the technique must be linked to the context
- random sampling; (1 identification mark)
- varied sample because everyone (in the population) has equal chance of being picked; 1 mark (generic) description
- e.g. should include people who express emotions easily and those who do not; 1 mark (linked) description
- He could use a random number generator on the GP patients list; 1 mark (generic) description
- so should get people with a variety of lifestyles/leisure pursuits / interests; 1 mark (linked) description
- [1] 1 mark for open question
- e.g. 'Explain how do you feel when you play sport/ read a book.'
- E.g. 'Why does camping make you feel relaxed?'
- e.g. 'Describe the last time you talked to someone about feeling emotional.'
- [2] 1 mark for disadvantage
- 1 mark for linking to study of emotion
- interpretation (of responses to open questions) may be biased (1 mark)
- researchers may be subjective (in their recording / interpretation of answers to open questions) (1 mark)
- If people do not like to mention their emotions, they will not want to do it in a study; so answers from people who are happy to talk about their emotions will be longer; (2 marks)
- People may find their emotions embarrassing; and this would be worse for open questions (where they have to express themselves in detail) than for closed questions; (2 marks)
- emotions are subjective; it will therefore be difficult to interpret the answers to open questions objectively; (2 marks)
- [2] At least one point must be linked to investigating emotions.
- it produces functional information (= 1 mark)
- so you can see which parts of the brain are active for different emotions (= 2nd mark linked)
- it produces very detailed information (about location of activity) (= 1 mark)
- so you could look at brains of emotional and non-emotional people (for differences) (= 2nd mark linked)
- [2] At least one point must be linked to investigating emotions.
- the scanner is very small / claustrophobic (= 1 mark)
- so you could not readily tell which emotions related to test and which to fear of situation (= 2nd mark linked)
- the scanner is very noisy (= 1 mark)
- this could distract / frighten the participant making the test of emotions less valid (= 2nd mark linked)
- The question is about fMRI, so answers saying 'no qualitative data' / disadvantages of quantitative data are irrelevant.
- However, answers that link the idea that quantitative data from scans of specific brain areas / activity is difficult to relate to the (subjective) experience of emotions are creditworthy
Write your answer and get it marked
On Oracle Prep you can write or photograph your own answer and have it marked by AI against this mark scheme, with feedback on what you missed.
Sign up free →