Skip to main content
A-LevelPsychologyOrganisational psychology9990/42 · May/June 2018 · Q415 Marks

For many years, Henry Mintzberg's ten managerial roles allowed the nature of leadership to be defined. However, it has never been clear how leadership relates to the way managers in organisations manage their workers.

  1. (a)Explain the relationship between leadership and managerial roles.[2]
  2. (b)Suggest one disadvantage of a participative/democratic style of leadership.[4]
  3. (c)Give two types of leader behaviour determined by how much they participate with their workers and how much they direct their workers.[4]
  4. (d)Discuss the advantages and disadvantages of determining leadership styles in organisations. You should include a conclusion in your answer.[5]

This question uses a diagram from the original paper, which isn't shown here. Open the full paper from the past papers archive to see it.

Mark scheme

Marking points from the official mark scheme (May/June 2018). The mark or mark type is shown in brackets.

  1. Marks: 1 mark for basic answer e.g. identification, 1 mark for elaboration/example.
  2. Most likely answer (other appropriate responses to be credited): Quote from Muczyk and Reimann 'Mintzberg identified ten managerial roles: (1) figurehead, (2) leader, (3) liaison, (4) monitor, (5) disseminator, (6) spokesman, (7) entrepreneur, (8) disturbance handler, (9) resource allocator, and (10) negotiator. Leadership, as we use the term in this article, concerns the leader role as Mintzberg defined it. This role describes the relationship between the manager and subordinates that results in the satisfactory execution of subordinates' assignments and, thereby, the attainment of the important goals of the organizational unit for which the leader is responsible. What's more, we agree with Mintzberg's contention that providing leadership is the most important of the ten managerial roles.'
  3. Marks: 1 mark basic answer, 2-4 marks determined by quality of answer/ elaboration (e.g. aspects of indicative content)
  4. Most likely answer (other appropriate responses to be credited): ∞ many managers have been forced to face the harsh reality that participative management simply may not work in some situations.
  5. ∞ leadership is a two-way street, so a democratic style will be effective only if followers are both willing and able to participate actively in the decision-making process. If they are not, the leader cannot be democratic without also being 'directive' and following up very closely to see that directives are being carried out properly.
  6. ∞ Sometimes decisions need to be made very quickly and the democratic style takes too long for a decision to be made.
  7. ∞ Sometimes decisions about pay and redundancies for example need to be made, which would not happen with a democratic style.
  8. Marks: 1 mark basic answer (e.g. identification of style), 2 marks description of type (e.g. Directive autocrat: low participation and high leader direction), x 2
  9. Most likely answer (other appropriate responses to be credited): Muczyk and Reimann (1987) outline the following two types: (1) the directive autocrat, (2) the permissive autocrat, (3) the directive democrat, and (4) the permissive democrat. Exhibit 1: Types of Leader Behaviors Degree of Participation in Decision Making: Low High Amount of Leader Direction: High Directive Autocrat Directive Democrat Low Permissive Autocrat Permissive Democrat
  10. Marks: Question requires discussion; always plural of each argument, and always requires conclusion. 1 mark for each advantage/disadvantage up to 4 max. 1 mark for conclusion.
  11. Most likely answer (other appropriate responses to be credited): Answers could focus on style as applied in an organisation OR could focus on measures used to determine styles. Advantage: ∞ if a leadership style is known then workers know how to behave/ how to follow the leader.
  12. ∞ Known styles may lead to more effective decisions being made by management teams (groupthink)
  13. ∞ If a Board of directors thinks style 'x' is best they are likely to appoint a leader who has style 'x'
  14. ∞ Psychometric measures can be used to determine styles
  15. Disadvantage: ∞ The measure to determine styles may be faulty/inappropriate/may not measure adequately.
  16. ∞ Knowing a style may not be a style suited to the efficient running of that organisation.
  17. ∞ Styles may be too rigid; situational leaders, for example, adapt to any given situation.
  18. Conclusion: any appropriate conclusion drawn from the discussion that has been presented.

Write your answer and get it marked

On Oracle Prep you can write or photograph your own answer and have it marked by AI against this mark scheme, with feedback on what you missed.

Sign up free →

About this question

Topic
Organisational psychology, A-Level Psychology (syllabus 9990). Structured question, 15 marks.
Source
A-Level Psychology, May/June 2018 Paper 4 Variant 2, question 4.

Questions and mark schemes are from past examination papers and remain the copyright of the exam board. How Oracle Prep builds its content

Related Psychology questions

© 2026 Oracle Prep