A geography student was studying local weather conditions. He decided to do an investigation of rainfall and wind direction at his school and at a coastguard station about 60km away. The locations of the school and coastguard station are shown on Fig. 8 (Insert). He tested the following hypotheses: Hypothesis 1: There is more daily rainfall at school than at the coastguard station. Hypothesis 2: There is more rainfall on days when the wind is blowing from the south and south west.
- (a)(i)To investigate the two hypotheses the student used a rain gauge and a wind vane. These are shown in Figs 9 and 10 (Insert). Suggest two factors which the student should have considered when deciding where to put the rain gauge.[2]
- (a)(ii)Describe how the student would have used the rain gauge to make his measurements.[3]
- (a)(iii)The student used a wind vane to observe wind direction. Suggest a good location to put the wind vane and explain your choice.[2]
- (a)(iv)Explain how a wind vane shows wind direction.[3]
- (b)(i)The student recorded the results of his measurements in a fieldwork diary which is shown in Table 2 below. Calculate the average (mean) daily rainfall for the 10 days in which measurements were taken. Insert your answer into Table 2.[1]
- (b)(ii)The student obtained secondary weather data for the same period of time from the coastguard station. This is shown in Table 3 (Insert). Often students get both primary and secondary data to investigate a hypothesis. Complete the table below which shows both types of data, by putting the following methods under the correct heading. Researching on the internet Using a barometer Measuring the speed of river flow Reading a newspaper report Primary data Secondary data Doing a pedestrian count Using an atlas map[2]
- (b)(iii)Suggest two ways in which the secondary data obtained from the coastguard station is more reliable than the primary data collected by the student.[2]
- (b)(iv)To compare the rainfall amounts at the school and the coastguard station the student plotted both sets of data onto a dispersion graph, Fig. 11 below. From Table 3 (Insert) add data to the dispersion graph to show the amount of rainfall at the coastguard station on Saturday 23rd.[1]
- (b)(v)The student decided that Hypothesis 1: There is more daily rainfall at school than at the coastguard station was false. What evidence from Tables 2 and 3 and Fig. 11 supports his conclusion?[3]
- (c)(i)To help him to reach a conclusion about Hypothesis 2: There is more rainfall on days when the wind is blowing from the south and south west, the student drew two graphs to compare wind direction and rainfall amounts. These are shown in Figs 12A and 12B below and opposite. Use the results in Table 3 (Insert) to draw onto Fig. 12B the SW wind direction bar at the coastguard station. Use the scale below Fig. 12A.[1]
- (c)(ii)Use the results in Table 3 to draw onto Fig. 12B the rainfall bar for Friday 15th. Use the scale below Fig. 12A.[3]
- (c)(iii)For the two places he studied, what conclusion would the student make about Hypothesis 2: There is more rainfall on days when the wind is blowing from the south and south west? Support your answer with evidence from Figs 12A and 12B. At school (Fig. 12A) At the coastguard station (Fig. 12B)[4]
- (d)Suggest why daily rainfall amounts vary between the school and the coastguard station. Use Fig. 8 (Insert) to help you to answer.[3]
This question uses a diagram from the original paper, which isn't shown here. Open the full paper from the past papers archive to see it.
Mark scheme
Marking points from the official mark scheme (Oct/Nov 2012). The mark or mark type is shown in brackets.
- [2] 7 (a) (i) Clear of buildings / away from shelter / open ground Clear of trees / away from interception Clear of people or animals / away from interference On grass not concrete / non-splash surface On flat land
- [3] (ii) Container stood firmly in ground / above ground / on ground Rainfall / water collects in measuring cylinder / rains into cylinder Read water level in measuring cylinder / read at eye level / read off the scale / read off the gauge Reading taken at same time every day / specific time period Empty water out of container Add any water collected in overflow cylinder
- [2] (iii) On the top of a building Away from obstruction / exposed to wind
- [3] (iv) Arrow turns / spins in the wind The arrow points the direction the wind is coming from The letters show direction / reference to compass direction
- [1] (b) (i) 4.8 (mm)
- [2] (ii) Primary data: using a barometer & measuring the speed of river flow Secondary data: researching on the internet & reading a newspaper report 4 correct = 2 marks, 2 or 3 correct = 1 mark, 1 correct = 0
- [2] (iii) Measurements made at same time of day No measurements are missing / all the days / everyday Measurements done with accurate or advanced instruments / recorded automatically or by computer Experienced or professional people / student error Answer could focus on weaknesses of student measuring 2 @ 1
- [1] (iv) Plot 2mm at coastguard station at day 2
- [3] (v) Average rainfall is higher at coastguard station / lower at school Paired data for 2 marks e.g. average daily rainfall 4.8 mm at school, 6.1 mm at coastguard station e.g. days with 8 mm rainfall or more (2/10 at school, 6/16 at coastguard station) e.g. up to 15 mm on one day at CG station, up to 12 mm in one day at school No Hypothesis mark
- [1] (c) (i) Plot wind bars: SW = 4
- [3] (ii) Plot rainfall bar: 1 mark for scales (up to 5mm & 15th); 1 mark for bar = 4 mm; 1 mark for position in SE quadrant
- [4] (iii) School: Hypothesis is not true / incorrect 1 mark reserve More rain on days when wind is from N/NW If answer is Hypothesis is true / partially true = 0 Rainfall is more than 5mm when wind is from N/NW & rainfall is 5mm or below when wind is from S/SW There is more total rainfall when the wind is from N/NW (26 mm) than when the wind is from S/SW (20 mm) Coastguard station: hypothesis is true / correct /more rain on days when wind is from S/SW – 1 mark reserve If answer is Hypothesis is not true / partially true = 0 Rainfall is more than 5mm when wind is from S/SW & rainfall is 5mm or below when wind is from N/NW / NE / SE There is more total rainfall when the wind is from S/SW (76 mm) than when the wind is from N/NW/NE / SE (22 mm) 1 mark for each hypothesis; 2 marks for supporting evidence
- [3] (d) Direction of wind varies from day to day More rain when winds blow from the sea More winds from sea / south affect coastguard station School is sheltered from winds off the sea or from south by hills / rainshadow School gets more rain when winds are from north Coastguard station is sheltered from north winds by hills / rainshadow 1 mark maximum for comparative location such as: CG station is nearer sea or CG station on coast & school inland CG station is at sea level & school is 200m above SL or school is higher
Write your answer and get it marked
On Oracle Prep you can write or photograph your own answer and have it marked by AI against this mark scheme, with feedback on what you missed.
Sign up free →