Students were concerned about how human activities may threaten the environment by causing air pollution. The students decided to focus on one problem caused by air pollution – the impact of acid rain in their region. First they researched acid rain and made a fact file. This is shown on Fig. 12 (Insert 2). The students decided to test the following hypotheses: Hypothesis 1 The acidity of rainfall is affected by the direction of the wind Hypothesis 2 Rainfall is more acidic after a period of dry weather
- (a)(i)State two human activities which could cause air pollution. 1 .......................................................................................................................................................... 2 ..........................................................................................................................................................[2]
- (a)(ii)Describe three effects of air pollution on the natural environment. 1 .......................................................................................................................................................... 2 .......................................................................................................................................................... 3 ..........................................................................................................................................................[3]
- (b)Look at Fig. 13 (Insert 2) which is a sketch map of the area where the students live. What is meant by the term prevailing wind?[1]
- (c)(i)The students realised that this investigation would be long-term, so they agreed to do their investigation every day for four months. They set up a recording station in the grounds of their school. Each day they recorded the following: • wind direction; • amount of rain that had fallen in the previous 24 hours; • pH value of any rainwater collected. They recorded their results as a data log. Part of this log is shown on Table 6 (Insert 2). Describe how they collected their data. Refer to equipment used in your answer. The answer for pH has been done for you. Wind direction ........................................................................................................................................ Amount of rain that had fallen ................................................................................................................ pH They used a pH meter or pH strips to measure the pH value of rainwater.[2]
- (c)(ii)Why did the students decide to do their investigation over four months?[2]
- (c)(iii)What difficulties might the students have had in collecting their data, which may have affected their results?[3]
- (c)(iv)Using their data log, they produced the summary in Table 7 (Insert 2). By studying this summary, what conclusion could the students make about Hypothesis 1 The acidity of rainfall is affected by the direction of the wind? What evidence from Table 7 supports their conclusion?[3]
- (c)(v)Use information from Figs 12 and 13 (Insert 2) to explain why the level of acidity in rainfall varies with wind direction.[3]
- (d)(i)Next, the students looked at Hypothesis 2 Rainfall is more acidic after a period of dry weather. Using their data log again, the students produced the summary in Table 8 (Insert 2). Use the results recorded in bold in Table 8 to complete the scatter graph, Fig. 14 (opposite) and draw in a best-fit line. [Figure 14][3]
- (d)(ii)The students accepted Hypothesis 2 Rainfall is more acidic after a period of dry weather. Do you agree with them? Support your answer with evidence from Fig. 14.[2]
- (e)(i)The students wanted to investigate the impact of another kind of pollution. Suggest a possible hypothesis about water pollution and describe appropriate data collection methods.[4]
- (e)(ii)Having completed their investigation of water pollution, what recommendations might the students have made to a water authority about how to reduce the level of pollution?[2]
This question uses a diagram from the original paper, which isn't shown here. Open the full paper from the past papers archive to see it.
Mark scheme
Marking points from the official mark scheme (Oct/Nov 2010). The mark or mark type is shown in brackets.
- [2] (a)(i) Burning fossil fuels; Burning coal; Burning oil; Burning vegetation; Smoke from steam train; Factories releasing gases into atmosphere; Exhaust emissions / fumes / gases from cars / planes; CFCs Spraying insecticides. 2 @ 1 marks
- [3] (a)(ii) Acid rain; Acidity increases in lakes; causing fish to die; Trees are damaged as acid water falls onto leaves; Soil water becomes acidic; which affects nutrient uptake to trees / plants; increased leaching; Global warming / enhanced greenhouse effect; Melting of ice caps; Rise in global temperatures; Increase in tropical storms; Enlarges hole in ozone layer
- [1] (b) Wind blows most frequently / most often / most common direction /main wind direction.
- [2] (c)(i) Wind vane / wind sock.; Rain gauge / measuring cylinder / container with measurements.
- [2] (c)(ii) Needed many measurements for reliability of results / fair results.; Take account of change in wind direction.; Takes some account of seasonal variation / no seasonal variation.; Get an average / total each month.
- [3] (c)(iii) It may have been difficult to take measurements every day for four months.; School holidays / access to school at weekends / forgetfulness / illness.; Difficult to take readings at the same time each day.; Measuring instruments are not very accurate.; Student error.; Equipment breaks.; Interference from other students / animals.; Difficult to measure small amounts of rainwater when recorded as trace.; Cannot take pH reading from a trace amount.
- [3] (c)(iv) Hypothesis 1 is correct / generally correct / partially correct ✓ Ha.; pH value is lower / more acidic when wind blows from the east.; Anomaly - North & South East have same pH.; Credit any two figures for 1 mark.
- [3] (c)(v) Power station / factories / motorways / airport / railway / CBD / urban area are located east of the school / upwind.; These are main sources of gases / chemicals / air pollution / sulphur dioxide / nitrogen oxide.; When wind blows from the east it carries these gases.; Deposits them on the school as acid rain when it rains.; Credit either reference to 'east'.
- [3] (d)(i) Plotting points: 2 @ 1 mark.; Draw in best-fit line = 1 mark.
- [2] (d)(ii) Yes, do agree with students ✓ Ha.; Graph shows as the number of dry days increase the average pH reading decreases / negative or inverse relationship.; As the number of dry days increases rainfall is more acidic.; Can use two sets of figures to compare. (e.g. 0 dry days = 5.7 pH, 10 dry days = 4.3 Ph)
- [4] (e)(i) Possible hypothesis ✓ Ha. (e.g. Water pollution of a stream increases downstream).; Survey study area and note possible pollution sources.; Select about 10 sites for more detailed survey.; Devise a recording sheet for measurements.; Possible tests, (e.g. clarity, survey of water species, water temperature, pH, water transparency, quantity of litter).; To 2 marks maximum.; Credit 1 mark for equipment / clothing.; Accept detailed description of methods for one test.
- [2] (e)(ii) Recommendations such as: Monitor pollution levels closely; Take action to reduce pollution levels / warning signs / litter / wardens / warn factories about level of pollution.; Legislation to prevent pollution / fines.; Education / publicity campaign to reduce pollution / make people aware that they are causing pollution.
Write your answer and get it marked
On Oracle Prep you can write or photograph your own answer and have it marked by AI against this mark scheme, with feedback on what you missed.
Sign up free →