The graph below is from the study by Yokley and Glenwick (1984) on the immunisation of pre-school children. intervention period first follow-up period second follow-up period 30 - 25 - cumulative percentage of children receiving one or more inoculations across time periods 20 - 15 - 10 - 5 - 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 week Key to different conditions — general prompt --- specific prompt -.-.- specific prompt plus increased access -.-.-.- specific prompt plus monetary incentive •• pooled control groups [Figure 3.1]
- (a)(i)Identify the condition in Fig. 3.1 which showed the most improvement in inoculation rate.[1]
- (a)(ii)Identify the condition in Fig. 3.1 which showed the least improvement in inoculation rate.[1]
- (b)Give two differences between the information given to the 'general prompt' group and given to the 'specific prompt plus monetary incentive' group.[4]
- (c)(i)Identify the two control groups in this study.[2]
- (c)(ii)Suggest why control groups were used in this study.[2]
- (d)Discuss the advantages and disadvantages of providing information about health using postal (mailed) prompts. You should include a conclusion in your answer.[5]
This question uses a diagram from the original paper, which isn't shown here. Open the full paper from the past papers archive to see it.
Mark scheme
Marking points from the official mark scheme (Feb/Mar 2019). The mark or mark type is shown in brackets.
- [1] Most effective was the 'specific prompt plus monetary incentive'.
- [1] Least effective was the 'pooled control groups'.
- [2] Difference 1: The 'specific prompt plus monetary incentive' group (MIG) received a monetary incentive ('$175.00 in cash prizes'), while the 'general prompt' group (GP) received no monetary incentive.
- [2] Difference 2: The MIG received details of specific immunisations needed, whereas the GP received information about the standardisation immunisation schedule but not specific inoculations needed.
- [2] Difference 3: The MIG involved a named child, while the GP did not involve a named child.
- [1] Contact control group (n=189) telephone contact but no mailing, no prompt information.
- [1] No-contact control group (n=191) no contact at all.
- [1] To see if there is a difference between experimental and control groups.
- [1] To test the effectiveness of different strategies using the non-contact group as a baseline when nothing is done by health authorities.
- [1] Advantages: Information can be described briefly or in more detail; can provide information or induce fear.
- [1] Advantages: People can read at their own leisure (in their own home), think about and then make decisions (without pressure from anyone).
- [1] Advantages: Prompts about health have been shown to be more effective than no prompts.
- [1] Disadvantages: People may not receive the mailing or receive it but never read it.
- [1] Disadvantages: People read the information but not act on it (or forget to act on it).
- [1] Disadvantages: People may delay acting (e.g., appraisal delay re Safer).
- [1] Conclusion: Any appropriate conclusion drawn from the discussion.
Write your answer and get it marked
On Oracle Prep you can write or photograph your own answer and have it marked by AI against this mark scheme, with feedback on what you missed.
Sign up free →