According to Chung and Naya (2000), studies have shown that only one third of all patients and less than 50% of asthma patients take their pills as prescribed. Using TrackCap™™, the following results were obtained. [Table: TrackCap™ compliance, Mean %, Median %, 80, 89]
- (a)Explain the difference between a mean and a median.[2]
- (b)Suggest one way in which the Chung and Naya study was ethical and one way in which this study was unethical.[4]
- (c)Give two reasons why a TrackCap™™ device may not be a valid measure of adherence.[4]
- (d)Discuss the advantages and disadvantages of using objective measures of adherence to medical requests. You should include a conclusion in your answer.[5]
This question uses a diagram from the original paper, which isn't shown here. Open the full paper from the past papers archive to see it.
Mark scheme
Marking points from the official mark scheme (Oct/Nov 2018). The mark or mark type is shown in brackets.
- (a) The mean is the sum of all the numbers in the set divided by the amount of numbers in the set.
- (a) The median is the middle point of a number set, in which half the numbers are above the median and half are below.
- (b) Ethical: Written informed consent was obtained after patients received a description of the trial's purpose and procedures. The informed consent form mentioned that compliance, pulmonary function and safety would be measured.
- (b) Unethical: Patients were not informed that compliance was under electronic surveillance so as not to introduce an unacceptable bias in favour of compliance.
- (c) Reason 1: The device was programmed to recognise, but not accumulate, multiple openings that occurred within 1 min of each other. If the cap was left off for 15 min or more, the device recorded one additional event. However, this does not mean the medication was taken. So just because the device records one instance of usage it does not mean the person has taken the medication.
- (c) Reason 2: There is no indication that the medication has been taken at the right time, i.e., at the times prescribed.
- (c) Reason 3: To prevent extraneous results, study personnel were asked not to open the bottles before, during, or after the study period, but this does not confirm patient adherence.
- (d) Advantages: objective measures involve no subjective comment (which may be dishonest answers) from a patient.
- (d) Advantages: objective measures provide quantitative data which can be statistically analysed.
- (d) Advantages: objective measures may involve measuring physiological processes out of the control of a patient.
- (d) Disadvantages: a patient should be allowed to comment, subjectively, on their own medication and why they may not be taking it.
- (d) Disadvantages: the objective measure may not be valid: the recording device only records the medication leaving the container (for example).
- (d) Disadvantages: objective measures give numbers; it does not give explanations.
- (d) Conclusion: any appropriate conclusion drawn from the discussion that has been presented. A conclusion is a 'decision reached by reasoning' and so a summary of points already made scores 0 marks.
Write your answer and get it marked
On Oracle Prep you can write or photograph your own answer and have it marked by AI against this mark scheme, with feedback on what you missed.
Sign up free →