Silly and conceited Well-intentioned and honest Which of these views do you think more accurately describes Shakespeare's portrayal of Dogberry? Support your answer with details from the play.

Mark scheme

Marking points from the official mark scheme (May/June 2011). The mark or mark type is shown in brackets.

1. Candidates should choose one of the statements and argue their case with reference to Dogberry’s character and actions in the play.
2. Good answers will explore the humour derived from his malapropisms and self-importance.
3. His ultimate effectiveness in uncovering the plot against Hero, despite his lack of intelligence.
4. Consider his desire for respect and authority (e.g., 'An ass, I am?'), and his devotion to duty.
5. The contrast between his foolishness and the serious consequences of the villains’ actions.
6. His well-meaning but often misunderstood attempts at justice.