Study Fig. 2.1, which shows Muslim astronomers.
- (a)Explain the methods used by 'Abbasid scientists in the development of science. You should refer to Fig. 2.1 and your own knowledge in your answer.[10]
- (b)Discuss the extent to which the 'Abbasids should be considered the first scientists. You should make reference to different points of view.[15]
This question uses a diagram from the original paper, which isn't shown here. Open the full paper from the past papers archive to see it.
Mark scheme
Marking points from the official mark scheme (May/June 2024). The mark or mark type is shown in brackets.
- [10] (a) The source shows Muslim astronomers. They are using instruments such as the astrolabe, developed by Muslims to accurately trace the course of the planets.
- [10] (a) This contrasts with much of the world at this time, who were looking at the stars with astrology and other superstitious notions in mind.
- [10] (a) Muslim scientists were observing the movements of the stars and using them to predict their future movement, a kind of scientific method based on rational deduction from observed evidence.
- [10] (a) Various other instruments can be seen, such as for taking measurements of angles. Mention might be made of al-Biruni, who measured the angle to the horizon to calculate, correctly, the circumference of the earth.
- [10] (a) This shows rational method at work, using logical deduction.
- [10] (a) Abu Bakr al-Razi observed carefully the illnesses of people and from this was able to distinguish smallpox and measles for the first time. Careful observation, noting of symptoms, was key.
- [10] (a) Ibn al-Haytham looked for the origin of light, tracing it back to the stars. The method of many 'Abbasid scientists was to look for origins, which ultimately came from God.
- [10] (a) Ibn al-Haytham formed theories that light travelled by the quickest route. He designed instruments to test his theory and deducted scientific rules about light and refraction.
- [10] (a) Most Abbasid scientists combined their work with philosophy, and religious discussion. Their methods did not divorce scientific evidence from Qur'anic teaching or evidence from religious tradition, which is very different from methods used by scientists today who, even if they have a personal faith, seek to prove science by experiment alone.
- [15] (b) Definitions: A definition of scientists and science could be made. This is an academic study using experiments, testing out theories or hypotheses, to derive scientific laws and understanding from observing and repeating what is seen.
- [15] (b) Agree: Professor Jim al-Khalili argues that Muslim scientist Ibn al-Haytham developed scientific method. He questioned everything and did not accept it until he found proof. Other religious thinkers at the time questioned whether the Qur'an was written by God at all.
- [15] (b) Agree: The context of scholarship in 'Abbasid Baghdad included discussion, debate and rational deduction – this applied in Islamic circles as well – and created the basis for scientific method to emerge.
- [15] (b) Agree: Many famous scientists emerged during this period, who used scientific method. Abu Bakr al-Razi developed Chemistry; Hunayn ibn Ishaq wrote a work on the eye and Ibn Sina wrote famous medical books. Each could be considered the first scientist in their field.
- [15] (b) Disagree: The Abbasids built on ancient Greek, learned and translated many of their texts. It could be argued that the 'Abbasids added little to the first scientists who were from the ancient world, and mainly copied their methods.
- [15] (b) Disagree: 'Abbasid science was constrained by beliefs: how the world was created and how things happen could not be explained without reference to God. Modern scientists might argue this is not truly rational or evidence based. The European enlightenment brought an age when true science began, unconstrained by religious dogma.
- [15] (b) Disagree: The Umayyads in Spain (al-Andalus) promoted at least as much scientific knowledge as the 'Abbasids, and should be equally given credit for the development of science.
- [15] (b) Conclusions: A judgement should be made as to how far the 'Abbasids could be considered the first scientists compared to others, such as ancient Greeks, modern Europeans or Umayyads.
Write your answer and get it marked
On Oracle Prep you can write or photograph your own answer and have it marked by AI against this mark scheme, with feedback on what you missed.
Sign up free →