Skip to main content
O-LevelGeographyPopulation and settlement2217/22 · Oct/Nov 2013 · Q830 Marks

Students from Auckland, New Zealand, were studying land-use in urban areas. One textbook model of land-use is shown in Fig. 12 (Insert). They decided to do some fieldwork to investigate land-use patterns in the city where they lived. The students investigated the following hypotheses: Hypothesis 1: Different types of land-use are located in different areas of the city. Hypothesis 2: There is a relationship between the main type of land-use and the height of buildings.

  1. (a)Give two reasons why there are different types of land-use in different parts of a city.[2]
  2. (b)(i)To collect fieldwork data the students decided to follow three transects from the Central Business District (CBD) to the edge of the city. Give three characteristics of the CBD of a city.[3]
  3. (b)(ii)The students decided to do their data collection at 10 sites along each transect. These are shown on Fig. 13 (Insert). Describe one way they could have chosen these sites.[2]
  4. (c)(i)At each sampling site the students recorded the ground-floor land-use of five buildings on each side of the road. Their results from one site are shown in Fig. 14 below. Ground-floor land-use Transect A site 3 Left side of road | Right side of road --- | --- House | House Apartments | House Newsagents | Apartments Tourist information office | Apartments Insurance office | Food shop Use this information to complete the following building classification which the students used. Use of building | Number of buildings at the site --- | --- Residential | (blank) Offices | (blank) Shops | (blank) Industry | 0[2]
  5. (c)(ii)Use the data below for site 4 on transect C to complete the divided bar graph for the site. Transect C site 4 Use of building | Number of buildings at the site --- | --- Residential | 2 Offices | 0 Shops | 1 Industry | 7 Divided bar graph of ground floor land-use at site 4 on transect C (Graph axes and key provided)[2]
  6. (c)(iii)The students decided to show only the main type of land-use at each survey site on their map of the city (Fig. 13 Insert). For site 4 on transect C, above, this was industry. Do you agree with their decision to show only the main type of land-use? Circle your choice below. Agree Disagree Explain why you agree or disagree.[2]
  7. (c)(iv)Fig. 13 (Insert) shows the results of the students' fieldwork. The students decided that Hypothesis 1: Different types of land-use are located in different areas of the city was correct. Support this decision with evidence from Fig. 13.[4]
  8. (d)(i)To investigate Hypothesis 2: There is a relationship between the main type of land-use and the height of buildings, the students counted the number of storeys of each building when they recorded its ground floor use. Suggest why this is an appropriate method of measuring the height of buildings.[1]
  9. (d)(ii)Then they calculated the average number of storeys at each site as shown in an example below. Transect A Site 3 Left side of road | Number of storeys | Right side of road | Number of storeys --- | --- | --- | --- House | 3 | House | 2 Apartments | 4 | House | 2 Newsagents | 2 | Apartments | 6 Tourist information office | 1 | Apartments | 6 Insurance office | 1 | Food shop | 3 Average number of storeys per building = 30/10 = 3 The results from all the sites on the three transects are shown in Table 5 (Insert). Use the data in Table 5 to complete Fig. 15 on page 26 (overleaf). You should plot sites 3 and 4 on transect C.[2]
  10. (d)(iii)What conclusion would the students make about Hypothesis 2: There is a relationship between the main type of land-use and the height of buildings? Support your answer with evidence from Table 5 and Fig. 15.[3]
  11. (d)(iv)Explain why there are buildings of different heights in a city.[2]
  12. (d)(v)A common weakness of studies of urban land-use is that data is only recorded for the ground floor level. Suggest why this is a weakness.[1]
  13. (e)One student wanted to extend her study by comparing the quality of the environment in different parts of the city. Describe how she could do this.[4]

This question uses a diagram from the original paper, which isn't shown here. Open the full paper from the past papers archive to see it.

Mark scheme

Marking points from the official mark scheme (Oct/Nov 2013). The mark or mark type is shown in brackets.

  1. [1 + 1 = 2] Historic growth from centre outwards/planning policy (1)
  2. Physical features with e.g. river valley/flat land/coasts. (1)
  3. Human features with e.g. railways/roads/accessibility (1)
  4. Value of land/price/cost (1)
  5. Natural resources with e.g. coal/minerals (1)
  6. Conflicting land uses with e.g. housing away from industry (1)
  7. Linked land-uses with e.g. low-cost housing close to workplaces/factories (1)
  8. High-class residential away from centre/CBD as was more space there (1)
  9. [1 + 1 + 1 = 3] Tall/multi-storey buildings/high land values (1)
  10. Focus of roads/railways/bus stations/railway stations/accessible from other areas (1)
  11. Car parks (1)
  12. Banks/offices (1)
  13. Large shops/department stores/chain stores/shopping centres (1)
  14. Pedestrianised area/lots of pedestrians/crowded (1)
  15. Historic/religious buildings (1)
  16. Public buildings/city hall/government buildings (1)
  17. Hotels (1)
  18. Air/noise pollution (1)
  19. Traffic congestion/rush hours/busy roads (1)
  20. Market place (1)
  21. [1 + 1 = 2] Systematic sample (1)
  22. e.g. every 100m/regular/equal/specific (1)
  23. Random sample (1)
  24. e.g. pick sites off a map/pick any site (1)
  25. use random numbers/tables to select sites (1)
  26. [1 + 1 = 2] Residential = 6
  27. Offices = 2
  28. Shops = 2
  29. 1 or 2 correct = 1; 3 correct = 2
  30. [1 + 1 = 2] Completion of divided bar graph: order 217 from left OR 217 from right
  31. Dividing lines = 1 mark (To be annotated beneath the plots)
  32. Shading = 1 mark (To be annotated by the key)
  33. [1 + 1 = 2] Agree: Simple data to plot (1)
  34. Easier to compare/analyse (1)
  35. Map will be too cluttered with graphs (1)
  36. Gives a clear picture (1)
  37. Quicker/faster to present/draw/map/record/show (1)
  38. Disagree: Loses detail of different types of building (1)
  39. May be fairly even split of land use/hard to choose main use (1)
  40. Credit either agree or disagree statements. If do both credit first
  41. [1+1+1+1 = 4] Residential areas are near waterfront/on edge of urban area/along transect A/in north-west/south/east/west (1)
  42. Office area is in the centre of city/in or near CBD/near docks (1)
  43. Shops area is along transect B/south of CBD (1)
  44. Industrial areas are near docks/close to motorway/along transect C/to south and east of CBD (1)
  45. [1] Easier/quicker to count number of storeys (1)
  46. Difficult to measure actual height of tall buildings (1)
  47. Can measure ground floor height and multiply by storeys (1)
  48. [1 + 1 = 2] Completion of sites 3 & 4 on transect C
  49. 10 Offices at 3; 4 Industry at 4.
  50. 1 mark for each bar correct with correct shading
  51. [1R + 1 + 1 = 3] Hypothesis is TRUE/CORRECT
  52. Evidence: More storeys/>10 storeys for offices OR more storeys/>4 for shops (1)
  53. Fewer storeys/<3 storeys for residential OR less storeys/<4 storeys for industry (1)
  54. More storeys in offices/shops than residential/industry (1)
  55. [1R + 1 + 1 = 3] Buildings are built higher where land values are high/relates to land value (1)
  56. Buildings are higher where there is less space/relates to space (1)
  57. [1] Ground floor use is often different from upper floors OR example e.g. might get flats above shops (1)
  58. [(1 + 3) or 2 x (1 + 1) = 4] Topic: e.g. Environmental quality survey/litter/air pollution/noise pollution/vegetation survey.
  59. (1 Reserve/2 max for valid topics)
  60. Techniques e.g. Choose different areas of city, e.g. industrial, residential, retail, open space (1)
  61. Carry out questionnaires (1)
  62. Interview people (1)
  63. Carry out bi-polar survey (1)
  64. Internet research must be qualified with a relevant aspect of the topic (1)

Write your answer and get it marked

On Oracle Prep you can write or photograph your own answer and have it marked by AI against this mark scheme, with feedback on what you missed.

Sign up free →

About this question

Topic
Population and settlement, O-Level Geography (syllabus 2217). Structured question, 30 marks.
Source
O-Level Geography, Oct/Nov 2013 Paper 2 Variant 2, question 8.

Questions and mark schemes are from past examination papers and remain the copyright of the exam board. How Oracle Prep builds its content

Related Geography questions

© 2026 Oracle Prep