Dani opened a music shop as a sole trader. Her speciality shop sells guitars and drums. Fig. 3.1 shows an extract of financial information for the business in 2023. [Table with Cash sales: $135540, Credit sales: $77850, Cost of sales: $61390, Other expenses: $111500] [Figure 3.1] Use Fig. 3.1 to help you answer the following questions.
- (a)(i)Calculate the profit for the year (net profit).[3]
- (a)(ii)State one reason why Dani accepts debit cards for cash sales.[1]
- (a)(iii)What is meant by credit sales?[1]
- (b)Define speciality shop.[1]
- (c)Do you agree that the most suitable form of business ownership for Dani is to be a sole trader? Give reasons for your answer.[3]
- (d)Dani wants to expand the business by investing in a guitar testing booth. She is considering two options to fund this expansion. Option 1: loan Option 2: overdraft. Discuss each of these two options. Which would you recommend? Give reasons for your answer.[8]
This question uses a diagram from the original paper, which isn't shown here. Open the full paper from the past papers archive to see it.
Mark scheme
Marking points from the official mark scheme (May/June 2024). The mark or mark type is shown in brackets.
- [3] (a)(i) Answer = $40 500
- [1] (a)(i) Method = $135 540 + 77 850 = $213 390
- [1] (a)(i) $213 390 – $61 390 = $152000 – $111500
- [2] (a)(i) OR $152 000 – $111500
- [1] (a)(ii) Payment is guaranteed/secure
- [1] (a)(ii) Immediate/instant payment/faster/direct payment / no credit
- [1] (a)(ii) No bad debts
- [1] (a)(ii) Reduces paperwork
- [1] (a)(ii) Security / prevents theft of cash
- [1] (a)(ii) Minimises cash handling
- [1] (a)(iii) Sale of goods on credit / goods bought on credit / payment is received later / buying now, pay later / in instalments / sales made through credit cards
- [1] (b) A shop that sells a narrow/restricted/limited range of goods/specific goods/niche goods/one kind of goods/one type of goods
- [3] (c) Up to 3 marks for justified reasoning of yes and/or no responses
- [1] (c) Yes - Dani will have full ownership
- [1] (c) be in complete control
- [1] (c) makes all business decisions
- [1] (c) no need to gain the approval of others
- [1] (c) can input own ideas
- [1] (c) receives all the profits
- [1] (c) no legal requirements when setting up
- [1] (c) has flexibility
- [1] (c) e.g. can take holidays when they like
- [1] (c) can adapt to changes quickly
- [1] (c) music shop is small, so can offer a personal service
- [1] (c) No - Has unlimited liability
- [1] (c) liable for all debts
- [1] (c) can lose personal possessions
- [1] (c) may find it difficult to raise finance
- [1] (c) to expand
- [1] (c) as sole traders considered risky to lend money to
- [1] (c) may have to work long hours / no holidays
- [1] (c) due to size unable to exploit economies of scale
- [1] (c) no continuity
- [1] (c) as business dies with owner
- [1] (c) might be better as a partnership/limited company
- [1] (c) more capital can be raised
- [1] (c) has more status than a sole trader
- [1] (c) can share losses/risks with
- [1] (c) shared decision-making
- [1] (c) more ideas
- [8] (d) Level 3 (7-8 marks): The candidate is able to offer a thorough evaluation, with a recommendation, of whether Dani should be using a loan or an overdraft to invest in new facilities.
- [8] (d) Level 2 (5-6 marks): Candidate offers a satisfactory analysis of the advantages and/or disadvantages of using a loan and/or overdraft to invest in new facilities without evaluation.
- [8] (d) Level 1 (1-4 marks): Candidate demonstrates some knowledge and understanding, with application to investing in new facilities, by a loan or an overdraft.
- [8] (d) Loan is a medium to long-term source of finance provided by banks with fixed interest charged on the sum borrowed.
- [8] (d) Overdraft is a short-term form of flexible borrowing up to an agreed limit using a bank current account.
- [8] (d) Loan: Would usually be repaid by monthly instalments over a set period of time, with a fixed rate of interest.
- [8] (d) Loan: It is a long-term source of finance usually for a large amount. Dani would receive a fixed amount.
- [8] (d) Loan: Normally used for a specific purpose, such as buying equipment, i.e. an asset such as fixtures and fittings because the bank will use it as security/collateral, but Dani might still need a deposit.
- [8] (d) Overdraft: Would enable Dani to spend more than she has in the bank, up to an agreed limit. Interest is charged on the amount overdrawn.
- [8] (d) Overdraft: Overdrafts tend to be used in the short term for working capital requirements – such as buying stock.
- [8] (d) Overdraft: The interest charged is likely to be higher than for a loan.
- [8] (d) Overdraft: Does not require much paperwork to complete.
- [8] (d) Overdraft: The overdraft can be received quickly and repaid at irregular intervals – when Dani has the money.
- [8] (d) Overdraft: Interest will be charged until she has repaid the overdraft in full.
- [8] (d) Evaluation: Dani needs finance for a specific project – for a guitar testing booth - so a loan seems most appropriate if she doesn't have enough cash available, but it will depend on how much the booth will cost. If it is a large amount of money, which would have to be repaid over a longer time, then a loan is again the recommended option, but if this facility costs a relatively small amount of money, Dani might just use her overdraft.
Write your answer and get it marked
On Oracle Prep you can write or photograph your own answer and have it marked by AI against this mark scheme, with feedback on what you missed.
Sign up free →