A-LevelBusiness StudiesHuman resource management9609/12 · Oct/Nov 2020 · Q520 Marks
Analyse how a business might satisfy the self-actualisation needs of its employees.
- (a)Analyse how a business might satisfy the self-actualisation needs of its employees.[8]
- (b)Discuss the significance of McGregor's leadership styles for managers in a hospital.[12]
Mark scheme
Marking points from the official mark scheme (Oct/Nov 2020). The mark or mark type is shown in brackets.
- [2] (a) Knowledge and Understanding: clear understanding of self-actualisation needs.
- [2] (a) Application: reference to self-actualisation needs in a business organisation or context (Maslow).
- [4] (a) Analysis: reaching one's full potential – needs are met in an organisation.
- [4] (a) Analysis: give employees challenging, fulfilling work.
- [4] (a) Analysis: job enrichment/enlargement/rotation might be used to facilitate self-actualisation.
- [4] (a) Analysis: opportunities to develop new skills – increase potential – become an expert.
- [4] (a) Analysis: recognition for work achieved – advancement, responsibility.
- [4] (a) Analysis: give new job titles – enhanced workspace – prestigious jobs.
- [4] (a) Analysis: increase workplace autonomy.
- [4] (a) Analysis: provide financial and non-financial rewards that recognise achievement and performance.
- [4] (a) Analysis: Accept any other valid response.
- [7-8] (a) Level 4: Good analysis of how a business might satisfy the self-actualisation needs of its employees.
- [5-6] (a) Level 3: Some analysis of how a business might satisfy the self-actualisation needs of its employees.
- [3-4] (a) Level 2: Application of how a business might satisfy the self-actualisation needs of its employees.
- [1-2] (a) Level 1: Knowledge and understanding of self-actualisation/employee needs.
- [2] (b) Knowledge and Understanding: clear understanding of McGregor's leadership styles (Theory X and Theory Y).
- [2] (b) Application: reference to use of McGregor's leadership styles by managers in a hospital.
- [2] (b) Analysis: the McGregor leadership styles theory – there are different attitudes of managers to worker depending on the culture of the organisation.
- [2] (b) Analysis: what determines the attitude of managers towards their workers and hence their leadership style?
- [2] (b) Analysis: explain how Theory X might lead to an autocratic approach – Theory Y to a more democratic approach.
- [2] (b) Analysis: there are many different types of workers in a hospital (e.g., nurses, doctors, support staff, administrators, managers).
- [2] (b) Analysis: do these different workers respond to different styles of leadership?
- [2] (b) Analysis: there are distinctive and different situations in hospitals (e.g., emergency situations on the ward or in the operating theatre which may require a Theory X approach).
- [6] (b) Evaluation: Judgement/conclusion as to the significance and relevance of McGregor's theoretical leadership styles to hospital managers.
- [6] (b) Evaluation: Contrasts may be made with other organisations and other managers.
- [6] (b) Evaluation: Discuss issues/problems hospital managers face and how Theory X and Y relate to them.
- [6] (b) Evaluation: Consider if Theory Y is more relevant to public service organisations.
- [6] (b) Evaluation: Discuss if public sector hospital managers differ from private sector (more accountable, controlled, complex demands).
- [6] (b) Evaluation: Consider if public service employees or service providers require different leadership styles.
- [6] (b) Evaluation: Acknowledge that different kinds of people work in hospitals with different needs and leadership styles.
- [9-12] (b) Level 4: Effective evaluation of the significance of McGregor's leadership styles for managers in a hospital.
- [7-8] (b) Level 3: Limited evaluation of the significance of McGregor's leadership styles for managers in a hospital.
- [3-6] (b) Level 2: Analysis and application of the use of McGregor's leadership styles for managers in a hospital.
- [1-2] (b) Level 1: Knowledge and understanding of Theory X / Theory Y / leadership styles / hospital managers.
Write your answer and get it marked
On Oracle Prep you can write or photograph your own answer and have it marked by AI against this mark scheme, with feedback on what you missed.
Sign up free →