Domestic goats are small, herbivorous animals that provide milk for human use. Goats' milk is an important source of food for people living in rural China. Xinong Saanen and Guanzhong are the names of two varieties (breeds) of goat common in China. In these breeds, there is genetic variation at nucleotide position 5752 of a gene coding for a growth factor. At this position there is either a cytosine (C) or a guanine (G) nucleotide. Some individuals are homozygous for the allele containing C at this position (CC), some are homozygous for the allele containing G at this position (GG) and some are heterozygous (CG). Table 2.1 compares the mean milk yield of the first milk-producing period (first lactation) and the next milk-producing period (second lactation) for Xinong Saanen goats of each genotype. [Table 2.1]
- (a)(i)Variation in a phenotypic characteristic such as milk yield is caused by a combination of genetic and environmental factors. Goats also show variation in milk yield between the first lactation and second lactation. Suggest, with reasons, whether the variation in milk yield between the first lactation and second lactation, as shown in Table 2.1, is genetic or environmental.[3]
- (a)(ii)The variation at position 5752 of the gene coding for a growth factor is due to a substitution mutation from G to C. With reference to Table 2.1, describe the importance of the substitution from G to C.[3]
- (b)(i)In a population of 268 Xinong Saanen goats: • the frequency of the C allele (q) is 0.30 • the frequency of the G allele (p) is 0.70. The Hardy-Weinberg principle can be used to predict the number of goats with CC, CG and GG genotypes in the population, using the equation: p² + 2pq + q2 = 1 For example, the number of goats with genotype GG can be predicted to be 131. Use the Hardy-Weinberg principle to predict the number of goats with genotypes CC and CG in this population of Xinong Saanen goats. number of goats with genotype CC number of goats with genotype CG[2]
- (b)(ii)A close match between your predicted figures in (b)(i) and the actual numbers in Table 2.2 would mean that the Xinong Saanen population is in Hardy-Weinberg equilibrium. State the name of a statistical test that could be used to find out whether or not the Xinong Saanen population is in Hardy-Weinberg equilibrium.[1]
- (b)(iii)The predicted numbers of goats with each genotype in the Guanzhong population according to the Hardy-Weinberg principle are: • CC = 16 CG = 135 • GG = 289. These figures are significantly different from the actual figures in Table 2.2. With reference to Table 2.2, describe the evidence that shows that the Guanzhong population is not in Hardy-Weinberg equilibrium and suggest reasons for this.[3]
- (c)Goats can be genetically modified to produce human proteins in their milk. In 2009, an anti-clotting protein produced in this way was approved for use as a drug in people who lack the protein. State one ethical advantage and one ethical problem of producing medicinal drugs from the milk of genetically modified goats. advantage problem[2]
Mark scheme
Marking points from the official mark scheme (Oct/Nov 2020). The mark or mark type is shown in brackets.
- [3] (a)(i) any three from: 1 environmental / not genetic; 2 as change in yield occurs in one goat; 3 yield increases (from 1st to 2nd) in all genotypes ; 4 older/2nd lactation, goats have, bigger / more developed, udders ; 5 age / maturity, is an environmental factor; 6 AVP;
- [3] (a)(ii) any three from: 1 (substitution / G → C / CC) increases milk, yield / production ; 2 more food / more income / benefit for people; 3 little difference between GG and CG/small effect in heterozygotes ; 4 AVP;
- [2] (b)(i) CC = (0.3 × 0.3 × 268 =) 24 ; CG = (2 × 0.3 × 0.7 × 268 =) 113 ;
- [1] (b)(ii) chi-square(d test) / x²;
- [3] (b)(iii) 1 CC, higher than predicted / 47 instead of 16 or GG, higher than predicted / 324 instead of 289 or CG, lower than predicted / 69 instead of 135; plus any two from: 2 could be (natural / artificial) selection against heterozygotes ; 3 could be (artificial) selection for, high milk yield / CC ; 4 migration/immigration / emigration ; 5 genetic drift; 6 non-random mating;
- [2] (c) advantage: 1 treat (genetic) disease / treat people / reduce suffering / therapeutic; problem (max 1): 2 possible side effects (on human) / drug may not be pure / may contain allergens / risk of harm / may be unsafe / risk of goat disease transmission to humans ; 3 process may harm goats / animal welfare issues ; 4 vegetarians/vegans, may not take drug;
Write your answer and get it marked
On Oracle Prep you can write or photograph your own answer and have it marked by AI against this mark scheme, with feedback on what you missed.
Sign up free →