Claude is looking for a link between time spent eating and hunger. He thinks that students who eat faster will be more hungry two hours later. He observes how much time some students spend eating their lunch. They are unaware that they are being observed. Two hours later, he asks them to rate their hunger on a scale of 1 to 10 (1 = not hungry, 10 = very hungry). He correlates how hungry they are with how much time they spent eating lunch. He finds there is a strong negative correlation between time spent eating and hunger.
- (a)(i)Label the x-axis and y-axis on the graph in Fig. 8.1.[2]
- (a)(ii)Draw a line to show Claude's correlation on the graph in Fig. 8.1.[1]
- (b)Explain whether Claude can conclude that eating faster makes people feel hungry.[2]
- (c)(i)Suggest one ethical strength of Claude's study.[2]
- (c)(ii)Suggest one ethical weakness of Claude's study.[2]
- (d)Claude's friend says that asking students to rate their hunger two hours after lunch may not be valid because some people may be in more interesting lessons than others. Explain why Claude's friend could be correct.[2]
This question uses a diagram from the original paper, which isn't shown here. Open the full paper from the past papers archive to see it.
Mark scheme
Marking points from the official mark scheme (Oct/Nov 2019). The mark or mark type is shown in brackets.
- [2] 1 mark for labelling an axis with 'Hunger' OWTTE 1 mark for labelling an axis with 'Time spent eating' OWTTE
- [1] 1 mark for points/a line showing a negative correlation (based on variables identified)
- [2] 1 mark for identifying a reason (can be generic) 1 mark for link No because the pattern could be due to a third factor; OWTTE (generic reason) No because you cannot draw causal conclusions from correlations; OWTTE (generic reason) For example, people could eat faster and feel more hungry because they were more hungry to begin with/had eaten longer ago (2nd mark, linked)
- [2] 1 mark for identifying a strength (can be generic) 1 mark for link He is observing students eating lunch (link) People know they are likely to be watched (strength) He is not invading their privacy; (strength) Because people know they are likely to be watched in a school dining room (link) He asks them rate their hunger; (link) which means they could choose to withdraw by not giving him this information (linked strength = 2nd mark) which means they have given consent to (part of) the procedure (alternative linked strength = 2nd mark)
- [2] 1 mark for identifying a weakness (can be generic) 1 mark for link He observes them eating without them knowing (link) So he has not obtained informed consent (weakness) He asks them to write down the time when they get hungry; (link) but they did not give consent to first part of the procedure (alternative weakness = 2nd mark) He observes them eating without them knowing; (link) So they were not able to withdraw (weakness) The students might notice they are being watched; (link) which could cause them distress/so they are not protected from (psychological) harm (weakness)
- [2] 1 mark for explanation relating to 'interesting lessons' 1 mark for explaining why this leads to a lack of validity If people are in interesting lessons they may not notice that they are hungry; (1 mark for explaining reason) this means he will be measuring whether they notice their hunger rather than whether they are actually hungry (or not) (1 mark for explaining why this lacks validity)
Write your answer and get it marked
On Oracle Prep you can write or photograph your own answer and have it marked by AI against this mark scheme, with feedback on what you missed.
Sign up free →