Skip to main content
O-LevelEconomicsThe allocation of resources2281/21 · May/June 2018 · Q720 Marks

More governments are imposing taxes on unhealthy food and drinks. Such taxes are usually regressive. Some of these governments are also increasing their spending on healthcare. In other countries healthcare is provided by the private sector. The number of state-owned enterprises is declining in a number of countries due to privatisation.

  1. (a)Define regressive tax.[2]
  2. (b)Explain why the social benefit of healthcare is greater than the private benefit.[4]
  3. (c)Analyse why a government imposes taxes.[6]
  4. (d)Discuss whether or not consumers are likely to benefit from state-owned enterprises becoming private sector firms.[8]

Mark scheme

Marking points from the official mark scheme (May/June 2018). The mark or mark type is shown in brackets.

  1. [2] A tax that takes a lower percentage of the income of the rich/higher percentage of the income of the poor.
  2. [1] A tax that falls more heavily on the poor.
  3. [1] Disadvantages the poor/higher burden on the poor/higher rate for the poor.
  4. [1] Social benefit includes both private and external benefits
  5. [1] Healthcare also provides external benefits
  6. [1] Example of private benefits identified as a private benefit e.g. profits of provider, wages of doctors, higher life expectancy of consumer (max 2).
  7. [1] Examples of external benefits identified as external benefits/recognised as 3rd party impacts e.g. higher labour productivity, higher output, reduction in spread of diseases (max 2).
  8. [1] To raise revenue
  9. [1] to finance government spending/example of spending
  10. [1] To discourage the consumption of certain products
  11. [1] example/external costs
  12. [1] To discourage the production of certain products
  13. [1] example/external costs
  14. [1] To discourage the consumption of imports
  15. [1] improve the current account position on the balance of payments
  16. [1] To redistribute income
  17. [1] taxing the rich more
  18. [1] To influence economic activity
  19. [1] raising taxes to reduce total (aggregate) demand
  20. [1] to control (demand-pull) inflation
  21. [1] There may be more competition in the markets
  22. [1] this may force down prices
  23. [1] increase quality
  24. [1] Firms will be influenced by the profit motive
  25. [1] this may make them more responsive to changes in consumer demand
  26. [1] State-owned enterprises may be slow in making decisions
  27. [1] due to bureaucratic control
  28. [1] may not respond quickly enough to consumer demands
  29. [1] State-owned enterprises might have taken into account social costs and social benefits
  30. [1] rather than just private costs and private benefits
  31. [1] main goal may be economic welfare
  32. [1] Private sector firms may merge
  33. [1] form monopolies
  34. [1] (use market power to) push up price
  35. [1] they may become complacent
  36. [1] lower quality
  37. [1] Private sector may not have sufficient finance for large-scale projects
  38. [1] consumers would lose out on the benefits

Write your answer and get it marked

On Oracle Prep you can write or photograph your own answer and have it marked by AI against this mark scheme, with feedback on what you missed.

Sign up free →

About this question

Topic
The allocation of resources, O-Level Economics (syllabus 2281). Structured question, 20 marks.
Source
O-Level Economics, May/June 2018 Paper 2 Variant 1, question 7.

Questions and mark schemes are from past examination papers and remain the copyright of the exam board. How Oracle Prep builds its content

Related Economics questions

© 2026 Oracle Prep