Refer to Appendix 2. Draw a decision tree using this information.
- (a)(i)Refer to Appendix 2. Draw a decision tree using this information.[4]
- (a)(ii)Calculate the expected monetary values for options A and B.[2]
- (b)Recommend whether KKS should choose option A or B. Justify your answer using your results from 4(a) and other information.[12]
This question uses a diagram from the original paper, which isn't shown here. Open the full paper from the past papers archive to see it.
Mark scheme
Marking points from the official mark scheme (Oct/Nov 2017). The mark or mark type is shown in brackets.
- [2] (a)(i) Drawing nodes and decision points
- [2] (a)(i) Correct figures entered
- [1] (a)(i) Some attempt at nodes/decision points
- [1] (a)(i) Some attempt at figures
- [0] (a)(ii) Option A Expected value at decision node = 50 × .4 + 35 × .6 = $41m
- [1] (a)(ii) Take off capital cost (−32) = $9m
- [1] (a)(ii) Use of probabilities or some attempt
- [0] (a)(ii) Option B Expected value at decision node = 90 × .3 + 40 x .7 = $55m
- [1] (a)(ii) Take off capital cost (-45) = $10m
- [1] (a)(ii) Use of probabilities or some attempt
- (b) Use of calculations: greatest EMV (Option A B2C = 9, Option B C2C = 10), – highest value chosen as greatest return/net profit. Is a difference of 1 significant?
- (b) Decision tree figures based on forecasts of sales and costs – how accurate are these? What might they be based on?
- (b) Three year time scale – what happens after that?
- (b) Option A offers highest profit but also greatest risk as competitive market and price sensitive consumers.
- (b) Option A market expanding rapidly but low margins mean a misforecast could be very costly
- (b) Option B (lowest forecast) also expanding and offers advantage of entering near start of rapid growth and gaining brand loyalty but has higher costs and is relatively more unknown
- (b) Use of Ansoff's matrix – Option A and B could be market development
- (b) Does KKS have the money for the additional operating costs for Option A and B?
- (b) Evaluation by justified recommendation based on consideration of the above or other relevant points.
Write your answer and get it marked
On Oracle Prep you can write or photograph your own answer and have it marked by AI against this mark scheme, with feedback on what you missed.
Sign up free →