Onions are vegetables that are harvested from the plant Allium cepa. In many countries, small onions are used to make pickled onions. Pickled onions can be stored for a long time because the growth of microorganisms is prevented. Pickled onions are made using this method. • Remove the dry outer layer from small onions. • Place the onions in a sodium chloride solution for several hours. • Remove the sodium chloride solution and place the onions in a solution of ethanoic acid (vinegar). Fig. 1.1 shows a container of pickled onions and some fresh onions that have not been pickled. dry outer layer of onion container of pickled onions fresh onion [Figure 1.1]
- (a)(i)Some students decided to investigate how placing small onions in different concentrations of sodium chloride solution affects the mass of the onions. Identify the independent variable in this investigation.[1]
- (a)(ii)The students were given a 20.0% stock solution of sodium chloride. The students decided to use the stock solution to make sodium chloride solutions with concentrations of 0.0%, 1.0%, 5.0%, 10.0%, 15.0% and 20.0%. The students made 140 cm³ of these solutions in separate beakers. Complete Table 1.1 to show how 140 cm³ of these solutions could be made by proportional dilution of the 20.0% stock solution of sodium chloride. Table 1.1 percentage concentration of sodium chloride solution volume of 20.0% sodium chloride solution /cm³ volume of /cm³ 0.0 1.0 5.0 10.0 15.0 20.0[2]
- (b)(i)The students carried out this procedure. • The dry outer layer was removed from 30 small onions. • Five of the small onions were placed into each of the six beakers containing the sodium chloride solutions prepared by the students. • The onions were left in the sodium chloride solutions for 2 hours. • The mean percentage change in mass of the five small onions in each beaker was calculated. The students then repeated the whole procedure using a new set of 30 small onions. This time the onions were left in the sodium chloride solutions for 48 hours. Fig. 1.2 shows the results of the investigation. [Figure 1.2] Explain why the students calculated the percentage change in mass of the onions.[1]
- (b)(ii)One of the students concluded that: The water potential of the onion cells is the same as the water potential of a 4.2% sodium chloride solution. With reference to the information provided, including the results shown in Fig. 1.2, suggest reasons why this conclusion should not be accepted.[4]
- (c)(i)The turnip, Brassica rapa, is a root vegetable. Turnips are grown in many parts of the world. Fig. 1.3 shows freshly harvested turnips with the leaves still attached. [Figure 1.3] A student decided to investigate the effect of temperature on the rate of osmosis in turnips. In an initial test, the student removed the outer layer from a turnip and cut the turnip into small blocks. The student placed one of the turnip blocks into a beaker of distilled water, as shown in Fig. 1.4. Water entered the block by osmosis. [Figure 1.4] The student was provided with additional turnips and standard laboratory apparatus. Describe a method that the student could use to investigate the effect of increasing the temperature, over a range from 10°C to 50 °C, on the rate of osmosis in turnip blocks. Do not include the risk assessment or how to calculate the rate of osmosis from the results. Your method should be set out in a logical order and be detailed enough to allow another person to follow it.[6]
- (c)(ii)Complete the sketch graph shown in Fig. 1.5 to predict the effect of increasing the temperature, over a range from 10°C to 50°C, on the rate of osmosis in turnips. Include axis labels with units in your answer. [Figure 1.5][2]
- (c)(iii)Suggest one hazard of your method in (c)(i), the risk associated with the hazard and the precaution that would need to be taken. hazard risk precaution[1]
This question uses a diagram from the original paper, which isn't shown here. Open the full paper from the past papers archive to see it.
Mark scheme
Marking points from the official mark scheme (Feb/Mar 2024). The mark or mark type is shown in brackets.
- [1] concentration of, sodium chloride (solution) ;
- [1] distilled water / deionised water / pure water (as diluent) ;
- [1] correct volumes of stock solution and water (in Table 1.1);
- [1] allows valid comparison (between onions in different sodium chloride concentrations) ;
- [1] allows comparison as, initial / starting, mass (of onions) is, not constant / AW ;
- [1] idea that the conclusion is only supported for onions left for hours; ora
- [1] (ref. to intercept of x-axis / 0% change in mass / water potential of onions when left for) 48 hours is 3.1% sodium chloride;
- [1] ref. to qualified experimental error ;
- [1] ref. to anomalous result(s) on graph;
- [1] idea that line of best fit may give different value ;
- [1] ref. to intermediate concentrations (of sodium chloride) not tested (between 1% and 5% sodium chloride) ;
- [1] ref. to no, statistical analysis / standard error / 95% CI ;
- [1] idea that not all onion cells have the same water potential;
- [1] use a minimum of five stated temperatures ;
- [1] suitable method to, maintain a constant temperature (for each replicate / experiment) ;
- [1] same / stated, variety / age / AW, of turnips ;
- [1] same / stated, dimensions / AW, of turnip block;
- [1] ref. to apparatus for obtaining same size of turnip blocks ;
- [1] for each temperature, place turnip blocks in, a beaker / AW, of (fresh / new) distilled water ;
- [1] at each temperature, measure the initial mass and the final mass after a, set / stated, time;
- [1] for each temperature, use at least three different blocks and calculate a mean ;
- [1] method to remove excess water from turnip block (before measuring final mass);
- [1] horizontal axis label: temperature, °C and vertical axis label: rate of osmosis ;
- [1] appropriately shaped line ;
- [1] ref. to hazard and risk and precaution ;
Write your answer and get it marked
On Oracle Prep you can write or photograph your own answer and have it marked by AI against this mark scheme, with feedback on what you missed.
Sign up free →