The genus *Heliconius* contains more than 40 species of brightly patterned butterflies. Researchers have investigated in the laboratory how one species, *Heliconius heurippa*, could have developed as a separate species. The phenotype of *H. heurippa* is intermediate between that of two other species, *H. cydno* and *H. melpomene*. Laboratory breeding experiments showed that: • matings between *H. cydno* and *H. melpomene* (parent species) produce fertile hybrid offspring • controlled matings of the hybrids produces individuals identical in appearance to *H. heurippa* within three generations • hybrid butterflies prefer to mate with each other, rather than with individuals of either of the parent species. The researchers concluded that the *H. heurippa* species could contain DNA from the two parent species as a result of hybridisation.
- (a)(i)Suggest, with reasons, one prediction that can be made about the chromosome numbers of *H. cydno* and *H. melpomene*.[2]
- (a)(ii)The researchers thought that, because the hybrid butterflies preferred to mate with each other, this could make speciation more likely to occur. Give reasons why the researchers thought that this made speciation more likely.[4]
- (b)*Heliconius* butterflies taste unpleasant to predators such as birds. The bright colours on the wings of the butterflies act as warnings so that birds avoid eating them. Individual birds have to learn which patterns to avoid. If one *Heliconius* species is abundant, or if it has a pattern shared with another similar species, predators learn to avoid this pattern faster. Therefore this pattern provides a selective advantage. In the wild, *Heliconius* hybrids occur in small numbers and have patterns that do not resemble the established warning pattern of either parent species. These hybrids have a selective disadvantage. This is an example of a post-zygotic isolating mechanism. Explain how selection against hybrids can act as a post-zygotic isolating mechanism.[2]
Mark scheme
Marking points from the official mark scheme (Oct/Nov 2019). The mark or mark type is shown in brackets.
- [2] 1 (chromosome numbers) are the same ; R similar numbers reasons any one from: 2 as hybrids are fertile / described; 3 two identical sets of chromosomes pair up / homologous chromosomes pair up / bivalents form (in meiosis); 4 meiosis occurs ;
- [4] any four from: 1 behavioural isolation ; 2 reproductive isolation ; 3 no gene flow with parent, species / populations ; 4 (so) hybrid gene pool maintained / AW ; 5 different mutations (occur in hybrid population to parent populations) ; 6 natural selection; 7 pre-zygotic isolating mechanism ; 8 sympatric (speciation) ;
- [2] any two from: 1 hybrids, are eaten / die / fail to reproduce; ora 2 hybrid gene pool not maintained; 3 parents better adapted ; 4 ref. to disruptive selection;
Write your answer and get it marked
On Oracle Prep you can write or photograph your own answer and have it marked by AI against this mark scheme, with feedback on what you missed.
Sign up free →