Bison are a type of large wild cattle. Ancestors of modern bison appeared in Asia 2.5 million years ago. This ancestral bison species increased its range into Europe and North America. While the ancestral species is now extinct, its descendants include Bison bonasus, the European bison, and Bison bison, the American bison. [Figure 5.1] shows an American bison.
- (a)After the end of the last ice age, populations of the ancestral bison were separated by sea and by forests that were not suitable as habitats. The separation resulted in the evolution of the European bison and the American bison. Explain how this separation resulted in the evolution of the two bison species.[4]
- (b)Table 5.1 compares features of European bison and American bison. Table 5.1 feature | European bison, B. bonasus | American bison, B. bison --- --- --- type of food | grass and higher vegetation such as leaves of bushes and trees | grass and low vegetation height/m | 2.1 | 2.0 maximum mass/kg | 1000 | 1270 Assess the relative importance of natural selection and genetic drift in producing the different heights and masses of the two species of bison.[3]
- (c)The European bison has a nuclear genome that is very similar to that of the American bison. The European bison has a mitochondrial genome that is more similar to that of wild cattle of the genus Bos than to the American bison. Discuss what this implies about the evolutionary history of the European bison.[3]
- (d)Outline how practical techniques could be used to test the hypothesis that farmed cattle are closely related to European bison.[4]
This question uses a diagram from the original paper, which isn't shown here. Open the full paper from the past papers archive to see it.
Mark scheme
Marking points from the official mark scheme (May/June 2022). The mark or mark type is shown in brackets.
- [4] any four from: 1 geographical isolation / barrier qualified ; Ignore separation 2 no, interbreeding / gene flow (between European and American populations); Ignore reproductive isolation here (needs to be late on in process) 3 different, environmental (conditions) / selection pressures ; 4 random / different, mutations ; 5 different, alleles selected for / gene pool / changes in allele frequency ; 6 populations have different, morphological / physiological / behavioural, features; 7 after, a long time / many generations, reproductive isolation occurs / cannot interbreed to produce fertile offspring; 8 allopatric (speciation);
- [3] any three from: 1 not possible / difficult, to come to a (reliable) conclusion ; A AW 2 small difference in height / heights are similar (so natural selection not more important than genetic drift); 3 taller/lighter, bison could be an advantage in reaching higher vegetation (so natural selection may be important); 4 difference in mass, may not be due to genetic factors / may be due to nutrient value of diet / may be due to quantity of food, (so natural selection may not be important) ; 5 genetic drift (in ancestral population) may have led to, European bison being, taller / lighter or American bison being, shorter / heavier;
- [3] 1 European bison has a, close / recent / common, ancestor with that of, cattle / Bos or European bison is more closely related to, cattle / Bos, (than to American bison); 2 European bison may have interbred with, cattle / Bos ; 3 mitochondria are inherited from, mother / female;
- [4] any four from: 1 obtain / use, blood / cells / tissue / DNA ; 2 from, both species / cattle and European bison ; 3 use PCR to, replicate / amplify, DNA ; 4 use, electrophoresis (described) / DNA profiling / DNA fingerprinting, to see genetic differences / compare the banding (patterns) ; 5 sequence DNA and, count / identify, (percentage) difference / similarity or sequence DNA and compare the, nucleotide / base, sequence ; 6 use, genome / DNA, microarray; R for gene expression 7 ref. to bioinformatics / database / (computer) software ; 8 similarity indicates, close relationship / more recent split ; 9 if they can breed to produce (viable) offspring (they are closely related) ;
Write your answer and get it marked
On Oracle Prep you can write or photograph your own answer and have it marked by AI against this mark scheme, with feedback on what you missed.
Sign up free →