A study by Snyder and DeBono (1985) used students to investigate how high self-monitors and low self-monitors evaluated different types of advertisements. Their results appear in Table 2.1, in which there is a maximum score of 12. Higher scores indicate greater favourability towards image-oriented advertisements and lower scores indicate greater favourability towards product-quality-orientated advertisements. [Table 2.1] Table 2.1 | Product | Canadian Club whisky | Barclay cigarettes | Irish Mocha Mint coffee | |---------------------------|----------------------|--------------------|-------------------------| | Self-monitoring category | High | 6.84 | 5.00 | 7.40 | | | Low | 4.88 | 3.68 | 6.08 |
- (a)Explain what the results in Table 2.1 indicate about how high self-monitors and low self-monitors respond to different types of advertising.[2]
- (b)Give two differences between the 'soft-sell' approach and the 'hard-sell' approach.[4]
- (c)Suggest how the validity of the stimulus materials (advertisements) used in the study could have been assessed.[4]
- (d)Discuss the strengths and weaknesses of using students in studies of consumer behaviour. You should include a conclusion in your answer.[5]
This question uses a diagram from the original paper, which isn't shown here. Open the full paper from the past papers archive to see it.
Mark scheme
Marking points from the official mark scheme (May/June 2019). The mark or mark type is shown in brackets.
- [2] Most likely answer (other appropriate responses to be credited): high self monitors favour image-oriented advertisements; low self monitors favour product-quality-oriented advertisements (as can be seen by looking at the rows in the table).
- [2] A wide range of answers is possible, so credit anything that is based on the table. Example below:
- [2] Marks: 1 mark e.g. both prefer Irish mocha mint coffee 2 marks both prefer Irish mocha mint coffee with numbers to support (e.g. 7.40 and 6.08). Note: any appropriate analysis receives credit. Note: re-writing question scores 0 marks.
- [4] Hard-sell = product (low self monitors); soft-sell = images and packaging (high self-monitors).
- [4] Quote from study (reorganised into differences): Soft-sell: create ads that appeal to the images associated with the use of the product, images that one may gain and project by using the product. Hard-sell: different ads, ones that focus on claims about the intrinsic merit, inherent quality, and functional value of the product itself.
- [4] Soft-sell: how a product is packaged by its advertising is as important as the product itself. Therefore, they tend to create advertisements that are very striking in their visual appeal; they pay close attention to the finer details of form and color. Typically, the copy associated with these ads emphasizes the image of the product or, more specifically, the images associated with the use of the product. Hard-sell: For these advertisers, it's the 'matter, not the manner' that counts.
- [4] Soft-sell: These image-oriented ads rarely, if ever, make any explicit mention of the quality of the product, and, indeed, little emphasis is placed on the product itself. Hard-sell: ads tell the consumer how good the product is, how well it works, or, with things to eat and drink, how good they taste.
- [4] Marks: 1 mark basic answer. 2 marks detail/elaboration x2. Note: descriptions of each max 1 mark each. Perfect answer 'x' does this; 'y' does that.
- [4] Most likely answer (other appropriate responses to be credited): Quote from study: As a check on the effectiveness of the manipulation, we presented 10 judges with the three sets of advertisements and, after every set, asked them, 'Which ad do you think is directed at concerns about product quality?' and 'Which ad do you think is directed at concerns about product image?' All of the judges correctly classified all of the advertisements into the image/product category.
- [4] Marks: 1-2 marks basic answer. 3-4 marks elaboration.
- [5] Marks: Question requires discussion; always plural of each argument, and always requires conclusion.
- [5] 1 mark for each advantage/disadvantage (however detailed) and related to the question up to 4 max. 2 marks max for two strengths/weaknesses unrelated to the question. 1 mark for conclusion.
- [5] Most likely answer (other appropriate responses to be credited): Strengths: students are consumers just like any other person.
- [5] students are readily available and in relatively large numbers
- [5] students may cost less: no travel expenses; course credits for 'payment' less advertising costs.
- [5] Weaknesses: students are less representative: are younger, less experienced, may not have worked, are more academic.
- [5] students are often WEIRD – Westernised, Educated, from Industrialised, Rich Democracies.
- [5] students may not have a choice – have to participate
- [5] students may know about the research and so unconsciously alter answers to fit aims of study
- [5] Conclusion: any appropriate conclusion drawn from the discussion that has been presented. 1 mark if appropriate. A conclusion is a 'decision reached by reasoning' and so a summary of points already made scores 0 marks.
Write your answer and get it marked
On Oracle Prep you can write or photograph your own answer and have it marked by AI against this mark scheme, with feedback on what you missed.
Sign up free →