Argentina announces lifting of currency controls Fig. 1 Argentina's foreign exchange reserves (monthly) [Figure 1.0] Source: CEIC Argentina's new government has removed foreign currency controls, allowing its citizens to buy US dollars freely for the first time in four years. These currency controls have been in place as part of a fixed exchange rate system. The move, which officials hope will boost the faltering economy, is the strongest President Macri has yet made in his bid to reduce the government interference that marked the country's economy under the previous presidencies. Removing foreign currency controls was the latest in a series of moves President Macri has made since he took office. His administration has also eliminated most farm export taxes and cut personal income taxes. The decision carries significant short term risks but equally big long term rewards if it leads to greater investment and lifts the country's failing export sector. In the short term, the move is likely to cause the biggest currency depreciation since Argentina's economic meltdown in 2002. Economists expect the Argentinian currency, the peso, to fall from its current official exchange rate of US1 = 9.8 peso to something closer to the rate used in the black (illegal) market, about US1 = 14.5 peso. This would be a fall of a third of its value. Lifting foreign currency controls came on the same day the US central bank raised its interest rate for the first time since 2006, making it relatively harder for other countries, including Argentina, to attract funds. A weaker peso will add to the country's already high inflation rate of 25%. To try to control price rises and attract funds, Argentina's central bank raised its interest rate to 38%. Amid rampant inflation and a lack of faith in the peso, Argentinian consumers and firms sought security in holding US dollars. Combined with rising demand from Argentina's government – which needed US dollars to make debt payments and pay for energy imports – this resulted in a shortage of US dollars in Argentina. To address this problem, former President Kirchner largely banned the sale of US dollars in 2011 but this led to the creation of a currency black market. The ban failed to contain inflation, which was among the world's highest throughout President Kirchner's term of office. Firms, meanwhile, struggled to obtain US dollars to buy parts and equipment, stifling growth and sometimes causing critical shortages at places like hospitals, which depend on imported supplies and equipment. Source: Wall Street Journal, 16 December 2015
- (a)(i)Explain how Argentina's high rate of inflation could cause downward pressure upon the official exchange rate of the Argentinian peso.[3]
- (a)(ii)Explain how managing the peso to maintain an official exchange rate has resulted in the change in Argentina's foreign exchange reserves shown in Fig. 1. Use a diagram to support your answer.[4]
- (b)Explain why fixing the price of the US dollar in terms of the Argentinian peso resulted in a black (illegal) market.[3]
- (c)Explain the factors that will determine whether the rise in the interest rate to 38% will lower inflation and attract funds into Argentina.[4]
- (d)Discuss the advantages of fixing the value of a currency at an official rate. Assess whether on balance a freely floating rate is more likely to be beneficial for Argentina.[6]
This question uses a diagram from the original paper, which isn't shown here. Open the full paper from the past papers archive to see it.
Mark scheme
Marking points from the official mark scheme (Oct/Nov 2017). The mark or mark type is shown in brackets.
- [3] For explaining that a high rate of inflation will reduce the competitiveness of Argentine goods and services (1 mark) and
- the impact of this on the current account of the balance of payments (1 mark) leading to an excess supply of peso in the foreign exchange market (1 mark) and as a result the peso would fall.
- Allow credit to those candidates who look at the high rate of inflation on capital flows: the high rate of inflation leads to an outflow of capital (1 mark), this leads to an outflow on the financial account (1 mark) leading to an excess supply of peso in the foreign exchange market (1 mark) and as a result the peso would fall.
- [4] For a diagram showing excess supply of Argentine peso at the official rate and an increase in demand from government purchase of the surplus.
- (1 mark) for showing the imposition of the official rate above the equilibrium
- (1 mark) for showing the excess supply that this would create
- (Up to 2 marks)
- For an accompanying explanation that the government purchases the surplus using its foreign exchange reserves (1 mark) and as a result the reserves fall (1 mark).
- (Up to 2 marks)
- [3] For explaining that there is a shortage of dollars at the official price as a result of demand exceeding supply; the value of the dollar is below equilibrium. In the free market, the price would rise.
- (1 mark)
- For explaining that the price of the dollar is not allowed to rise in the official market because the price is fixed.
- (1 mark)
- For explaining that the price will, however, rise in the black (illegal) market.
- (1 mark)
- [4] For an explanation of the factors that will determine whether inflation will be curbed; this will depend on the extent to which consumption (C) and investment (I) expenditure is sensitive to the change in the interest rate.
- (Up to 3 marks)
- For an explanation of the factors that will determine whether funds will be attracted into Argentina.
- (Up to 3 marks)
- 4 marks maximum
- [6] For an explanation of the advantages of a fixed rate (the disadvantages of a freely floating rate).
- (Up to 4 marks)
- For an explanation of the disadvantages of a fixed rate (the advantages of a freely floating rate).
- (Up to 4 marks)
- 5 marks maximum
- For a concluding comment on whether on balance a floating rate is better for Argentina.
- (1 mark)
- 6 marks maximum
Write your answer and get it marked
On Oracle Prep you can write or photograph your own answer and have it marked by AI against this mark scheme, with feedback on what you missed.
Sign up free →