Skip to main content
A-LevelBusiness StudiesStrategic ManagementMay/June 2024Paper 4 Q120 Marks

Luxury Cars (LC) LC is a manufacturer of luxury cars based in the US. Its customers expect LC to use premium materials in its cars. Customers are willing to pay higher prices than those charged by LC's competitors. The company's reputation for 'affordable luxury' is critical to its promotional strategy. LC's main customer markets are in the US and Europe. These two geographical areas were originally operated as individual profit centres. LC employed experienced design engineers and market research teams in each area. This ensured LC met the distinct customer needs in each area. Timeline of LC 2009-2013 LC struggles to recover from the global financial crisis which reduced consumers' disposable incomes. 2014 New Chief Executive, Juan Pedro, appointed [Appendix 1]. 2015 Organisational structure changes from geographical to functional areas. Inventory management and budgets controlled centrally by US head office. 2016 LC develops an enterprise resource plan in response to budgetary constraints [Appendix 2]. 2017-2018 LC closes its least profitable, labour-intensive factories. 2019 LC reduces its product range. 2020 LC invests in one new capital-intensive factory financed by a bank loan. 2021 Employee contracts are changed to improve workforce flexibility [Appendix 3]. 2022 Labour productivity decreases and labour turnover increases. 2023 Board of Directors reviews LC's financial performance [Appendix 4]. A new Human Resource (HR) strategy A recent SWOT analysis indicated to the Board of Directors that LC has lost the support of its employees when it introduces strategic changes which directly affect them. There has been a loss of experienced workers with design and IT skills. This has led to a reduction in overall output across all factories. Productivity is 30% lower than projected. LC has received feedback from its employees [Appendix 5]. Appendix 1: press release announcing LC's new CEO in 2014 LC has appointed Juan Pedro, a former Finance Director, as its new Chief Executive. Juan is eager to use his experience to introduce strategic changes which will cut costs. Juan promises 'higher dividends will be paid to shareholders within the next ten years.' Appendix 2: extracts from LC's enterprise resource plan in 2016 • Centralised finance department to allocate all costs and calculate profit margins. • Monthly financial reports to be sent to head office to monitor performance and decision-making. • Inventory holding costs to be minimised. Appendix 3: new production employee contracts in 2021 • Change from salary to time-based contracts. • All bonuses removed. • Guaranteed working week reduced from 40 to 20 hours. • All hours worked, including overtime, paid at standard hourly rate. • LC's contribution to employee pensions reduced. Appendix 4: ratio results based on LC's financial statements 2014 to 2023 | | 2014 | 2017 | 2020 | 2023 | |-------------------------|------|------|------|------| | Gross profit margin | 40% | 50% | 60% | 40% | | Operating profit margin | 5% | 4% | 8% | 6% | | Rate of inventory turnover (times) | 12 | 15 | 24 | 24 | | Gearing | 40% | 40% | 65% | 63% | | Current ratio | 1.2:1| 1:1 | 1:1 | 1:1 | | Acid test ratio | 0.4:1| 0.7:1| 0.8:1| 0.8:1| | Dividend yield | 2% | 1% | 1% | 5% | Appendix 5: feedback from employees in 2024 'The new contracts state 20 hours but I'm expected to work 45 hours most weeks with no increase in hourly rate.' 'Why should the impact of strategic change always fall on workers?' 'I've got to do two jobs now because LC's contract only guarantees 20 hours.' 'We are never involved in any decision making.' 'I've never worked in a worse job!' 'I feel like just another machine in the automated factory.' Evaluate LC's business performance between 2014 and 2023.

✓ Correct Answer

The correct answer is . This question tests the candidate's understanding of strategic management within the Business Studiessyllabus. The examiner's mark scheme requires...

📋 Examiner Report & Trap Analysis

Common mistake: 62% of candidates selected the distractor because they confused... The examiner specifically designed this question to test whether students can differentiate between... To secure full marks, candidates must demonstrate...

🔒

Unlock the Examiner's Answer

Sign up for free to reveal the correct answer, the official mark scheme breakdown, and the examiner trap analysis for this question.

Sign Up Free to Unlock →

Join thousands of Cambridge students already using Oracle Prep

About This A-Level Business Studies Question

This structured question appeared in the Cambridge A-Level Business Studies (9609) May/June 2024 examination, Paper 4 Variant 1. It tests the topic of Strategic Management and is worth 20 marks.

Oracle Prep provides AI-powered practice for all Cambridge O-Level and A-Level subjects. Our platform includes topic predictions with 87.7% accuracy, AI essay grading, and a comprehensive question bank spanning 25 years of past papers.

© 2026 Oracle Prep — The AI-Powered Cambridge Exam Engine