Fruits in the diet can be a source of vitamins, such as vitamin C and vitamin A, which are important in maintaining good health. Vitamin A is a group of molecules that includes retinol and retinal. Vitamin C is an organic acid known as ascorbic acid. Ripening occurs in fruit when molecular changes cause an increase in sugar content, colour changes and softening of the fruit, over time. Ascorbic acid is found in plant cells. The fruits of many plants have high concentrations of ascorbic acid. A student planned to investigate how ascorbic acid concentration changes with ripeness in the fruit of the apple tree, Malus domestica. The fruit of M. domestica (apples) are shown in [Figure 1.1].
- (a)(i)The student removed an apple that was 5cm in diameter from a tree. The student measured the sugar content of the apple, which was low. This indicated that the apple was at the early stages of ripening (unripe). For the investigation, the student decided to select apples from trees when each apple was 5 cm in diameter. The student assumed that the ripeness of each apple would increase each day after it had been picked from a tree. Suggest why the diameter of the apples selected may not give accurate estimates of ripeness.[1]
- (a)(ii)Describe an improvement to the method for selecting the apples that would give more accurate estimates of ripeness.[1]
- (b)The student researched how ascorbic acid concentration changes with ripeness in the fruit of other species. Based on this research, the student predicted that ascorbic acid concentration in apples will: • be lowest in unripe apples when they are first picked from the tree • increase over several days and peak in partially ripe apples • decrease slightly in later days as the apples become fully ripe. Sketch a line graph below, including labelled axes, to show the predicted results.[2]
- (c)(i)The student used the redox indicator DCPIP to investigate how ascorbic acid concentration changes as the apples ripen. The student tested the ascorbic acid concentration of the apples at intervals from the time they were taken from the tree until the apples were fully ripe. For each test, the student prepared an apple extract solution and reacted this with a DCPIP solution of standardised concentration. The student was provided with a 0.01 moldm⁻³ stock solution of DCPIP. After preliminary research, the student decided to dilute the stock solution to prepare a 0.0005 mol dm⁻³ DCPIP solution to use in the experiment. The student used two steps to dilute the stock solution to the 0.0005moldm⁻³ DCPIP solution. Complete the description of the two steps for the dilution by adding the correct values to the sentences. step 1 The student mixed 10 cm³ of 0.01 mol dm⁻³ DCPIP stock solution with ............ cm³ of distilled water to produce solution A. Solution A had a concentration of 0.001 moldm⁻³. step 2 The student then mixed ............ cm³ of solution A with 50cm³ of distilled water to produce the 0.0005 moldm⁻³ DCPIP solution.[2]
- (c)(ii)DCPIP changes colour from blue to colourless when it is reduced by ascorbic acid. • The volume of DCPIP that can be reduced by ascorbic acid is a measure of the concentration of ascorbic acid present in a solution. • When all the ascorbic acid present in a solution has reacted with DCPIP, any more DCPIP that is added will remain blue. The student had access to standard laboratory equipment and a burette. DCPIP solution can be added to a burette and released one drop at a time by turning a tap. [Figure 1.2] shows a burette set up for this investigation. Describe a method the student could use to: • prepare apple extract solutions from the fruit • collect the results needed to show the changes in ascorbic acid concentrations as the apples ripen, using DCPIP. The description of your method should be set out in a logical way and be detailed enough for another person to follow. You should not repeat the details from (c)(i) describing how to dilute the 0.01 moldm⁻³ stock solution of DCPIP.[9]
- (d)After recording the results, the student decided that Pearson's linear correlation was a more appropriate test to use than Spearman's rank correlation to test whether ripeness and ascorbic acid concentration were correlated. Suggest two reasons why Pearson's linear correlation was the more appropriate statistical test.[2]
- (e)Many fruits are a good source of β-carotene, which can be converted in the human body to vitamin A. The student investigated the β-carotene content of apples. The student measured the β-carotene concentration in ripe apples and the ripe fruit of four other species. [Figure 1.3] shows the results. The student concluded that apples are not a good dietary source of vitamin A. Use the data in [Figure 1.3] to evaluate this conclusion.[3]
This question uses a diagram from the original paper, which isn't shown here. Open the full paper from the past papers archive to see it.
Mark scheme
Marking points from the official mark scheme (Oct/Nov 2023). The mark or mark type is shown in brackets.
- [1] any one from:
- [1] 1 idea that size (of apple) may not be, related / proportional, to ripeness;
- [1] 2 idea that (individual) apples may, ripen at different rates / AW ;
- [1] 3 idea that other factors may affect, ripeness of apples / diameter of apples ;
- [1] any one from:
- [1] 1 (pick apples with the) same / similar / AW, sugar content/colour / softness / age;
- [1] 2 test/measure / AW, sugar content / colour / softness / age (of apples) ;
- [2] 1 correct axis labels ;
- [2] 2 correct shaped line;
- [2] 1 90;
- [2] 2 50;
- [9] any nine from:
- [9] 1 idea of test on at least 5 days;
- [9] 2 use apples from same, tree / variety / type ;
- [9] 3 use, same / stated, storage conditions (of apples);
- [9] prepare apple extract solutions:
- [9] 4 remove the, skin / seeds, of the apple ;
- [9] 5 use, set / stated, mass of apple;
- [9] 6 method to, grind / AW, apple ;
- [9] 7 centrifuge / filter ;
- [9] measure ascorbic acid concentration using DCPIP:
- [9] 8 place, set/ stated, volume of (apple extract) solution in, conical flask / AW ;
- [9] 9 idea of adding DCPIP dropwise to (apple extract) solution until blue colour remains ;
- [9] 10 shake/mix/AW (after each drop of DCPIP) ;
- [9] 11 measure/ record, volume of DCPIP used (to reach end point);
- [9] 12 read volume from bottom of meniscus (in burette);
- [9] 13 use at least three replicates for each day and calculate a mean (DCPIP volume);
- [9] 14 safety comment with hazard and risk and precaution; hazard: DCPIP, risk: irritant / toxin /allergy, precaution: gloves / goggles / mask / PPE; hazard: apples, risk: allergy, precaution: gloves / goggles / mask / PPE/medication / do not eat; hazard: knife / scalpel, risk: injury, precaution: cut away from hand
- [2] any two from:
- [2] 1 data is continuous ;
- [2] 2 scatter diagram, suggests a linear, relationship;
- [2] 3 data is normally distributed ;
- [3] any three from:
- [3] for the conclusion:
- [3] 1 apples have the second lowest ẞ-carotene concentration (of the fruits shown);
- [3] 2 quoted data from Fig. 1.3 to support ;
- [3] 3 idea that spread of data for apple is lower (than most fruits that were tested, as SD is smaller)
- [3] against the conclusion:
- [3] 4 idea that need to calculate, SE / 95% CI (to make a conclusion);
- [3] 5 no statistical test carried out ;
- [3] 6 idea that only 5 fruits were tested ;
Write your answer and get it marked
On Oracle Prep you can write or photograph your own answer and have it marked by AI against this mark scheme, with feedback on what you missed.
Sign up free →