Parkinson's disease occurs when nerve cells in part of the brain die, resulting in less secretion of a neurotransmitter called dopamine. Dopamine is involved in the control of muscle movement and in emotional responses. As a result, common symptoms of Parkinson's disease are muscle twitching and stiff muscles. Other symptoms can include depression, memory loss and problems with sleeping. The disease is progressive, so over time the symptoms become worse.
- (a)(i)Scientists collected data on the number of males and females with Parkinson's disease in specific age groups in the USA. Fig. 2.1 shows these data presented as number of people with Parkinson's disease per 100 000. [Figure 2.1] State what conclusions can be made from Fig. 2.1 about Parkinson's disease in the USA.[3]
- (a)(ii)A student suggested that the Spearman's rank correlation could be used to test the relationship between age and the occurrence of Parkinson's disease. Give a reason why it is possible to use the Spearman's rank correlation to analyse the data shown in Fig. 2.1.[1]
- (a)(iii)State a null hypothesis for this test.[1]
- (b)(i)There is currently no cure for Parkinson's disease although a range of treatments can be used to relieve the symptoms. Drugs are given that are absorbed by brain cells and converted to dopamine. As the disease progresses, more brain cells die and so less of the drug is absorbed. As a result, the effectiveness of these drugs decreases. Research into the use of neural stem cells (NSC) as a more effective treatment for Parkinson's disease is being carried out. One study was carried out to test the hypothesis that: The use of a Chinese herbal drug increases the differentiation of NSC into neurones that produce dopamine. In this study, 48 healthy male rats of similar mass were randomly divided into four groups. Each rat was kept in a separate cage and supplied with food and water. Fig. 2.2 shows the experimental design of the study. [Figure 2.2] Identify two variables that have been standardised in this study.[2]
- (b)(ii)Suggest one variable that should have been standardised in this study but for which there is no information about how this was done.[1]
- (c)At 7, 14 and 28 days after the start of the study, a sample of four rats from each group was tested to find the dopamine concentration in the brain. The results are shown in Table 2.1. [Table 2.1] State two advantages of calculating standard deviations (s) in studies of this type.[2]
- (d)The researchers concluded that, in rats, the use of a Chinese herbal drug increases the differentiation of NSC into neurones that produce dopamine. With reference to all the information about this study, give one piece of evidence that supports this conclusion and one piece of evidence that suggests this conclusion is not valid. evidence that supports this conclusion evidence that suggests this conclusion is not valid[2]
This question uses a diagram from the original paper, which isn't shown here. Open the full paper from the past papers archive to see it.
Mark scheme
Marking points from the official mark scheme (Feb/Mar 2020). The mark or mark type is shown in brackets.
- [3] any three from:
- 1 idea of the number of cases (per 100 000) increases with age;
- 2 the number of men (per 100 000) with Parkinson's disease is higher than women / higher proportion of men than women develop Parkinson's disease / ora;
- 3 greatest increase in cases occurs between 60–69 and 70–79 age group ;
- 4 number of cases in men increases at all ages or in women number of cases decreases at ages above 79 years ;
- 5 no, cases / symptoms, in under 30-year olds or cases / symptoms, start at 30 and above ;
- [1] any one from:
- data can be ranked ;
- at least five pairs of data;
- graph suggests there is an increasing relationship;
- [1] there is no correlation between age and the number of cases (per 100 000) of Parkinson's disease ;
- [2] any two from:
- 1 number of rats in each group / 12 rats per group ;
- 2 sex of rats / all male rats ;
- 3 volume of saline given / 4 cm³ saline given ;
- 4 time at which saline / treatment / injection / medication / AW, given ; or saline / treatment / injection / medication / AW, given at, same / stated, times ;
- 5 mass of rats / all rats within ± 20 g;
- 6 health of rats / all rats, healthy;
- [1] any one from:
- age of rats;
- number of NSC per injection / AW ;
- type of, food / nutrient ;
- mass of, food / nutrient ;
- time of feeding;
- same, type / size, of cage;
- type / species, of rat ;
- environmental temperature;
- idea of stress / movement;
- volume of water;
- concentration of saline ;
- type / volume / mass / dose, of chemicals to induce Parkinson's disease ;
- [2] any two from:
- 1 shows the spread of data (about the mean) ;
- 2 allows, calculation / determination, of standard error / confidence intervals ;
- 3 allows determination of whether or not there is a significant difference (between mean values) or allows, t-test to be calculated / statistical test (of significant differences between means) ;
- 4 to plot error bars on, graphs / bar charts ;
- [2] supports conclusion:
- 1 the concentration of dopamine is (significantly) higher in the, NSC and Chinese herbal drug group / group 4, than in the, NSC only group / group 3 ;
- suggests not valid (max 1):
- 2 only, a small number of rats / 12, rats in each test group ;
- 3 increased dopamine production may not be correlated with more differentiation of NSCs ;
- 4 study only for 28 days ;
- 5 idea of at 28 days dopamine levels in treatment 4 have dropped ;
- 6 at 14 days group 3 and 4, differences may not be significant / standard deviations overlap / share an overlap at 57.4 ;
- 7 no control for Chinese herbal drug in Parkinson's disease rats without NSC ;
- 8 only male rats ;
Write your answer and get it marked
On Oracle Prep you can write or photograph your own answer and have it marked by AI against this mark scheme, with feedback on what you missed.
Sign up free →