Skip to main content
A-LevelBiologySelection and evolution9700/42 · Oct/Nov 2020 · Q213 Marks

Domestic goats are small, herbivorous animals that provide milk for human use. This is an important source of food for people in rural South Africa. Three Northern European goat varieties (breeds) have been imported to South Africa because they have higher milk yields than the native South African goats. Table 2.1 compares the mean daily milk yields of these three breeds of Northern European goat in three locations, Northern Europe, Barbados and South Africa. [Table 2.1]

  1. (a)Native South African goats have a mean daily milk yield of 0.25 kg. Calculate how many times greater the mean daily milk yield will be if a native South African goat is replaced by the Northern European goat breed that gives maximum yield. Show your working and write your answer to two significant figures. answer[2]
  2. (b)(i)Explain how the data in Table 2.1 support the claim that some of the variation in mean daily milk yield in goats is due to genetic causes.[2]
  3. (b)(ii)The climate, vegetation and availability of veterinary care for goats in Northern Europe, Barbados and South Africa are different. Explain how Table 2.1 shows that environmental factors can cause variation in mean daily milk yield in goats.[2]
  4. (c)Native South African goats are better adapted to the local conditions in South Africa than a Northern European breed, such as the Saanen. However Saanen goats have the potential for very high milk yield. Outline a programme of selective breeding that could produce a goat with a high milk yield that is adapted to the local conditions in South Africa.[5]
  5. (d)Children in developing countries may drink unpasteurised goats' milk. Some may develop diarrhoea caused by live bacteria ingested in the milk. Scientists have used genetic engineering to develop goats that produce human lysozyme in their milk. Lysozyme is an enzyme that kills bacteria and so reduces the number of bacteria in the milk. State a social advantage and a social disadvantage of making these GM goats available in developing countries. advantage disadvantage[2]

This question uses a diagram from the original paper, which isn't shown here. Open the full paper from the past papers archive to see it.

Mark scheme

Marking points from the official mark scheme (Oct/Nov 2020). The mark or mark type is shown in brackets.

  1. [2] 1.45 – 0.25 = 1.20
  2. [2] 1.20 ÷ 0.25 = 4.8
  3. [2] allow ecf for mp2
  4. [2] 1.45 ÷ 0.25 = 5.8
  5. [2] or
  6. [2] 5.17 – 0.25 = 4.92 ;
  7. [2] 4.92 ÷ 0.25 = 20 ;
  8. [2] allow ecf for mp2
  9. [2] 5.17 ÷ 0.25 = 21
  10. [2] any two from:
  11. [2] 1 different breeds at, same / named, location / environmental conditions, / have different milk yields ;
  12. [2] 2 comparative data quote including units ;
  13. [2] 3 (different breeds have) different gene pools / different alleles ;
  14. [2] 4 due to selective breeding;
  15. [2] any two from:
  16. [2] 1 same breed has different milk yields in, different location / named location / environmental conditions;
  17. [2] 2 comparative data quote including units ;
  18. [2] 3 how, climate / vegetation / veterinary care, affects milk yield ;
  19. [5] any five from:
  20. [5] 1 human applies selection pressure / artificial selection ;
  21. [5] 2 breed Saanen goat with, local / South African, goat;
  22. [5] 3 select offspring with, desired characteristics / high milk yield / adaptation to local conditions ;
  23. [5] 4 breed offspring (with desired characteristics);
  24. [5] 5 repeat (selection and breeding of offspring) for, several / many, generations ;
  25. [5] 6 ref. to progeny testing / test milk yield in female offspring of male goats ;
  26. [5] 7 avoid inbreeding / out-cross to unrelated goats;
  27. [5] 8 directional selection;
  28. [5] 9 AVP; e.g. carry out programme in South Africa
  29. [2] any one advantage:
  30. [2] 1 stops / reduces, diarrhoea (in children);
  31. [2] 2 improves children's, nutrition / growth / development ;
  32. [2] any one disadvantage:
  33. [2] 3 safety risks unknown / potential allergen / side effects;
  34. [2] 4 may disrupt ('good') bacteria / AW ;
  35. [2] 5 expensive;
  36. [2] 6 not willing to drink GM milk ;

Write your answer and get it marked

On Oracle Prep you can write or photograph your own answer and have it marked by AI against this mark scheme, with feedback on what you missed.

Sign up free →

About this question

Topic
Selection and evolution, A-Level Biology (syllabus 9700). Structured question, 13 marks.
Source
A-Level Biology, Oct/Nov 2020 Paper 4 Variant 2, question 2.

Questions and mark schemes are from past examination papers and remain the copyright of the exam board. How Oracle Prep builds its content

Related Biology questions

© 2026 Oracle Prep