Populations of European ash trees, Fraxinus excelsior, are susceptible to a chronic tree disease called ash dieback. Since 2012, this disease has spread through Europe causing large-scale loss of woodland. • Ash dieback is caused by a fungal pathogen. • Symptoms include stem lesions, death of growing shoots and wilting of leaves. • To limit the spread of the disease, 693 hectares of ash woodland were cleared in the UK between 2012 and 2015. Clearing the woodland involved uprooting the trees and burying them. [Table 2.1] shows the numbers of new cases of ash dieback in a variety of different environments in the UK between 2013 and 2015.
- (a)(i)Calculate the percentage change in the number of new cases of ash dieback in plant nurseries, between 2013 and 2015. Show your working and give your answer to the nearest whole number. ............................................................................................................................................................................ %[2]
- (a)(ii)Describe and explain the differences between the changes in the numbers of cases of ash dieback from 2013 to 2015 in the environments shown in [Table 2.1].[2]
- (b)(i)Explain how the cDNA in samples from the ash trees hybridises onto the microarray slide.[1]
- (b)(ii)Suggest how the level of each gene expression is determined.[1]
- (c)(i)Explain why it was important that samples from healthy trees were taken from trees growing next to very heavily diseased trees.[1]
- (c)(ii)Describe how the study ensured that a diverse range of ash trees was selected for sampling.[2]
- (c)(iii)The scientists who carried out the study assessed the degree of damage caused by ash dieback in each ash tree using a six-point scale, as shown in [Table 2.2]. Suggest why a numeric scale was used to record the degree of damage to the trees caused by ash dieback.[1]
- (d)(i)State which base is associated with tolerance to ash dieback.[1]
- (d)(ii)Suggest how a change in one nucleotide base could result in a change of tolerance to a pathogen.[1]
This question uses a diagram from the original paper, which isn't shown here. Open the full paper from the past papers archive to see it.
Mark scheme
Marking points from the official mark scheme (Oct/Nov 2019). The mark or mark type is shown in brackets.
- [2] plant nurseries = (−) 69 (%) ;;
- [2] descriptions of: woodland and roadside, increase in number of cases, (over 2013–2015)
- [2] or nurseries (and gardens) and farmland, decrease in number of cases (over 2013–2015);
- [2] explanations as ideas of: 1 (more) difficult to manage, 'wild' environments / woodland / roadside, ora
- [2] or 2 as woodland and roadside, cover a large area / far from centres of habitation, so, many trees to get infected / hard to get access for management difficult to access, ora
- [2] or 3 disease spreads (more) easily, in, dense woodland, ora
- [2] or 4 ref to burying diseased trees could provide a reservoir of infection
- [2] or 5 idea of number of reported findings have increased as awareness of ash dieback has spread / AW ;
- [1] complementary base pairing;
- [1] idea of intensity / brightness, of, fluorescence / fluorescent dye / colour
- [1] or difference in intensity of, fluorescence / fluorescent dye / colour, (between healthy and diseased samples);
- [1] (these trees) are (likely to be) tolerant / resistant
- [1] or (these trees could be) a source of, tolerance / resistance, genes / alleles / mRNA / DNA
- [1] or idea of comparing non-diseased and diseased trees ;
- [2] any two of: multiple / several / many / 4, locations;
- [2] varying ages ;
- [2] from differently sized populations ;
- [2] from, different countries / from across Europe ;
- [2] varying degree of damage / healthy and non-healthy, sampled ;
- [2] A description of a suitable, random / systematic, sampling technique for 1 mark if no other mp awarded.
- [1] any one of: to allow (easier) comparison of data (from different sites) ;
- [1] to allow (easier) analysis (of results) ;
- [1] (easier) to plot, as graph / bar chart;
- [1] idea of (bioinformatic) analysis will be carried out by a computer;
- [1] guanine / G;
- [1] idea of (mutation causes) a change in, protein / polypeptide / enzyme, which changes, function / tolerance / resistance
- [1] or (mutation causes) a change in, protein / polypeptide / enzyme, that allows the plant to, respond to infection / repair damage
- [1] or (mutation causes) a change in, protein / polypeptide / enzyme, that prevents the pathogen from, entering / spreading in, the ash plants ;
Write your answer and get it marked
On Oracle Prep you can write or photograph your own answer and have it marked by AI against this mark scheme, with feedback on what you missed.
Sign up free →