In some countries crops are irrigated using water containing salt (sodium chloride). This makes the soil saline (salty) which means it contains sufficient neutral soluble salts to reduce the growth and yield of most crop plants. The responses of crop plants to salinity vary between two extremes: • sensitive - plants show the greatest reduction in growth and yield • tolerant - plants show the least reduction in growth and yield. Agricultural research organisations have investigated the effect of irrigation with salt solutions on the yields of a variety of crop plants. The data collected allowed researchers to determine, for each crop, the concentration of salt solution at which yield is reduced by 50%. From the data recommendations could be made about which crops were most suitable to grow in saline soils. Table 2.1 shows the crops tested. [Table 2.1: grasses (monocotyledons) and broad leaf crops (dicotyledons) for human consumption (Triticum aestivum, Hordeum vulgare, Solanum tuberosum, Brassica oleracea, Spinacia oleracea) and animal grazing (Festuca arundinacea, Agropyron cristatum, Medicago sativa)] • Seeds were germinated in salt-free conditions. • Young plants were planted into fields that were divided into standard test plots of the same area for each crop. • Each field was irrigated regularly with a different concentration of salt solution. • Control plots were irrigated with salt-free water. • Each crop was grown to maturity and harvested. • The dry mass of the edible parts of the plants was measured to find the yield for each concentration of salt solution.
- (a)(i)Identify one variable that could be standardised once the young plants are in the test plots in the fields.[1]
- (a)(ii)Suggest one other variable that cannot be standardised once the young plants are in the test plots in the fields.[1]
- (b)Suggest why the researchers used dry mass to estimate the yield of the different crops.[2]
- (c)The data collected by the researchers allowed them to determine, for each crop, the concentration of salt solution at which yield is reduced by 50%. Explain how the researchers determined the concentration of salt at which yield is reduced by 50%.[2]
- (d)Fig. 2.1 shows the results of this investigation. [Figure 2.1] State three conclusions that can be made about the effect on the yield of these crops when irrigated with salt solutions.[3]
- (e)Based on these results the agricultural organisations published recommendations to help farmers choose which crops to grow in saline soils. However, farmers in different parts of the world who followed these recommendations did not obtain the yields expected. Suggest two reasons for this. 1 2[2]
Mark scheme
Marking points from the official mark scheme (Oct/Nov 2017). The mark or mark type is shown in brackets.
- [1] any 1 from: volume of (salt) solution used for irrigation ; time (of day or length of watering time) at which irrigated (in the field plots); any other added nutrient / fertiliser used on the crop plants ;
- [1] any 1 from: temperature; (sun)light (availability); rainfall / soil water; humidity / wind ; (variation in) soil pH ; other soil feature e.g. drainage / fertility / nutrients already present / aeration / type of soil ; pests / disease ;
- [2] idea of water content of the (different) crops / plants will vary ;
- [2] to allow comparison between different crops / plants ;
- [2] (dry mass) is the organic matter/biomass ;
- [2] plot the yields for each crop on a graph (including for control plots irrigated with water) ; A annotated sketch
- [2] use intercept at 50% / half the yield to find salt concentration; A annotated sketch or find the yield / dry mass of control and halve / find 50% ; A in an equation showing percentage loss find which of the concentrations gives yield that is closest match to half the control; A in an equation showing percentage loss
- [3] any 3 from: 1 the growth monocotyledons are less affected than dicotyledons ; ora
- [3] 2 potato growth is most decreased by salinity / most sensitive ;
- [3] 3 barley growth is least decreased by salinity / most tolerant ;
- [3] 4 all (crop / yields) are affected by / are sensitive to (saline) ;
- [3] 5 all dicotyledons are reduced by narrow(er) range of concentrations / concentrations between 1.0–1.3 g dm⁻³ or monocotyledons are reduced by a wide(r) range of concentrations / concentrations between 2.3–4.8 g dm⁻³;
- [3] 6 no crops have 50% yield reduction in concentrations below 1.0 g dm⁻³ ;
- [2] any 2 from: 1 ref. to different environmental conditions ;
- [2] 2 does not allow for different cultivation methods / examples of different methods of cultivation ;
- [2] 3 seeds are planted directly in saline soil / seeds are not pre-germinated in salt-free conditions ;
- [2] 4 does not allow for build-up of salinity from irrigation ;
Write your answer and get it marked
On Oracle Prep you can write or photograph your own answer and have it marked by AI against this mark scheme, with feedback on what you missed.
Sign up free →