Fig. 4.1 is a transmission electron micrograph of the bacterium that causes cholera, Vibrio cholerae. The flagellum shown in Fig. 4.1 allows movement of the bacterium within the gut and may also function to help it to bind to an intestinal epithelial cell. The organism does not enter the cell but the toxin it releases can enter and cause damage. Large quantities of water, chloride ions and sodium ions are lost from the cell. People with symptoms of cholera have severe watery diarrhoea and as a result can become very dehydrated. [Figure 4.1]
- (a)Explain how a loss of chloride ions and sodium ions from the intestinal epithelial cell will cause a loss of water from the cell.[2]
- (b)The main treatment for cholera is oral rehydration therapy (ORT) using oral rehydration salts (ORS). This involves drinking a solution of electrolytes (mineral ions) and glucose. Fig. 4.2 summarises the movement of glucose and sodium ions across an intestinal epithelial cell. [Figure 4.2] Fig. 4.2 includes three different types of cell surface membrane proteins: • SGLT1 is a cotransporter protein • GLUT2 and Na⁺/K⁺ pump are two types of carrier protein. The first rehydrating solution developed for the treatment of cholera did not contain glucose. Using ORS, patients absorb a higher concentration of sodium ions and there is an increase in water uptake. With reference to Fig. 4.2: • outline the transport mechanisms that result in the movement of glucose and sodium ions across the intestinal epithelial cell • suggest how the movement of glucose and sodium ions increases water uptake by the cell.[4]
- (c)In severe cases of cholera, the rehydrating solution is given intravenously, as a drip directly into a vein. Suggest one reason why the rehydrating solution is given as a drip directly into a vein rather than into an artery.[1]
- (d)In very severe cases of cholera, antibiotics are also prescribed. The preferred antibiotic for treatment of cholera is a single dose of doxycycline, a form of tetracycline antibiotic. Tetracycline binds to a ribosomal subunit. Suggest what effect this will have on the metabolism of V. cholerae.[1]
- (e)(i)A study was carried out to compare the effectiveness of the antibiotic tetracycline in the treatment of 118 patients with cholera. The patients were divided into four different treatment groups: • Group A, given one dose of 1 g tetracycline • Group B, given one dose of 2 g tetracycline • Group C, given a multiple dose (one dose of 500 mg tetracycline every 6 hours for 24 hours) • Group D, no antibiotic given. Following treatment, the volume of diarrhoea collected from each patient was measured every 16 hours for 128 hours. Fig. 4.3 shows the mean volume collected for each group. [Figure 4.3] Describe the trends shown in Fig. 4.3.[3]
- (e)(ii)Explain whether the results support, or do not support, treating very severe cases of cholera with tetracycline.[2]
- (f)Some strains of V. cholerae are antibiotic resistant. Explain why this means that medical practitioners prefer to treat cholera with a single dose of antibiotic, rather than a multiple dose of the same antibiotic.[2]
- (g)Most people who have recovered from cholera rarely become ill again from the disease. In these people, antibodies have been identified that will bind either to the cholera toxin, or to the bacterial flagellum, or to the main bacterial cell. Explain why the antibodies are different, each one specific to its target.[3]
- (h)Evidence suggests that newborn babies of mothers who have had cholera have immunity to the disease. State precisely the type of immunity these babies are likely to have.[1]
This question uses a diagram from the original paper, which isn't shown here. Open the full paper from the past papers archive to see it.
Mark scheme
Marking points from the official mark scheme (Oct/Nov 2017). The mark or mark type is shown in brackets.
- [2] two from
- (loss of ions) increases / AW, water potential within cell; ora, A Ψ for water potential, I ref. to solutes / solute potential
- water moves out of cell, down water potential gradient / from high(er) to low(er) water potential ; R from high to low water potential gradient
- (out) by osmosis / through the partially permeable membrane ; A selectively permeable membrane I osmotic gradient
- [4] four from
- capillary side sodium ions
- 1 sodium ions out (of cell), by active transport / with use of ATP ; A sodium ions pumped out
- 2 (so) lowers concentration of sodium ions within cell or sodium ion concentration gradient, set up / maintained ;
- intestinal lumen sodium ions and glucose
- 3 sodium ions enter by facilitated diffusion ; A diffusion / high to low concentration, through, SGLT1/cotransporter I glucose enters by facilitated diffusion
- 4 glucose, cotransported with sodium ions into cell (through SGLT1) ; A sodium ions cotransported with glucose A glucose enters by secondary active transport, A idea of glucose only able to enter if moving with sodium ions (i.e. sodium drives the process)
- 5 (cotransport means) glucose enters against concentration gradient ;
- capillary side glucose
- 6 glucose out of cell (towards capillary) by facilitated diffusion ; A by diffusion if stated through, membrane protein / GLUT2
- water uptake from lumen
- 7 (higher concentrations of) sodium ions / glucose / solutes, within cell lowers water potential ;
- 8 water follows, sodium ions / glucose / solutes (osmotically) or so water enters cell (down water potential gradient) ; must have idea that it follows inward movement of solutes
- [1] any one valid e.g.(if not stated artery or vein, assume vein)
- high(er) pressure of artery (will not allow drip)
- or artery may be deeper to reach to insert needle for drip / easier to find vein A vein more, visible / superficial
- or greater risk / more complications / greater blood loss, associated with intra arterially AW
- [1] one from
- no/reduced, polypeptide / protein, synthesis
- or mRNA not translated / no translation / reduced translation; A detail of translation e.g. tRNA cannot bind R DNA not translated
- or no/few, enzyme-catalysed reactions ;
- [3] three from
- 1 volume / AW, decreases over time for all groups;
- 2 compared to no antibiotic antibiotic groups, steep(er) / faster, decrease to, 32/48 hours ;
- 3 idea that diarrhoea, stops / is 0 dm³, at / after, 64 hours, for one dose 1 g/ A, or, multiple dose / C ; A recovers after 64 hours / AW
- 4 after 48 hours, one dose 2 g / B, fluctuation / decreases then (slight) increase then decrease / AW ;
- 5 no antibiotic / D, higher volumes diarrhoea than antibiotics (to approx. 110h) or no antibiotic / one dose 2 g / B, took 128 hours (for diarrhoea) to, reach 0 dm³/ stop ;
- 6 multiple dose / C, higher volumes than, A (all readings) / B (to 48 hours) ora or A has steepest decrease in context of 16-32 hours or overall
- [2] alternative ways to refer to decrease in volumes of diarrhoea may be in terms of recovery, destroying bacteria, decreasing loss of glucose and salts
- two from
- support treatment
- there is a difference between antibiotic and no antibiotic treatment or fast(er) decrease in volume of diarrhoea with antibiotics / AW or (generally) faster recovery with antibiotics; I ref. to one dose 2 g
- use of Fig. 4.3 to support;
- e.g. use (1 dose) 1 g or multiple dose
- time, to recover/reach 0 dm³, is halved
- use of numerical data from Fig. 4.3
- does not support treatment
- (in all cases) volume decreased to, same level / zero or all patients recovered ;
- use of Fig. 4.3 to support;
- e.g. by 128 hours all patients 0 dm³
- one dose of 2 g same trend from 112 hours as no antibiotic
- one dose of 2 g patients relapse after 64 hours
- one dose of 2 g took 128 hours (for recovery)
- not able to say
- limited information available / small number of patients;
- ref. to one dose of 2 g antibiotic ; e.g. does not reach 0 dm³ until same time as no antibiotic
- also see arguments above – allow once only here or for does not support
- [2] answer may be from point of view of single dose or multiple dose
- allow AW - note mp 3 is for starting with susceptible bacteria and mp 4 is for starting with resistant bacteria
- penalise once if use virus throughout
- single dose
- 1 easier to be sure patient has taken complete dose
- 2 if (bacteria are all susceptible and) treatment completed, all bacteria killed / no reservoir of bacteria
- 3 (susceptible so) no bacteria survive to, mutate / become resistant
- 4 idea that (if resistance is already present) single stronger dose has greater chance of killing resistant bacteria
- 5 (if all killed with single dose) idea that resistance not transferred (if all killed) e.g. no vertical / horizontal, transmission this could be suggested as follow up to mp 2/4
- multiple dose
- course may not be completed
- treatment may not be completed so some (susceptible) bacteria survive
- (bacteria replicating so) increased chance of, mutation / becoming resistant
- weaker dose spread over time, resistant bacteria, more likely to survive / have less chance of being killed
- if resistant / if develop resistance, this could be transferred A vertical / horizontal, resistance
- 6 AVP
- e.g.
- one dose may mean, no / less, antibiotic enters environment (in faeces)
- (more effective so) bacteria passed out for shorter time, so reduces risk of transmission (of pathogen)
- idea that multiple low dose antibiotics may increase mutagenesis
- suggestion that if resistant and not killed by antibiotic, there may be less of an effect on (good) gut bacteria with single dose
- [3] three from
- 1 ref. to different antigens (in context of, flagellum / whole cell / toxin); A ref. to epitopes instead of antigens
- 2 specificity ; in correct context (B-lymphocytes/plasma cells/antibodies/antigen binding sites)
- 3 detail of B-lymphocytes; e.g. specific B-lymphocytes activated (by each different antigen) A clonal selection form plasma cells that release specific antibody, A B-lymphocytes release specific antibody
- 4 detail of antibody; I ref. to receptor
- e.g. antibody complementary (shape) to antigen, antigen binding sites on antibody, variable regions different for each antibody
- [1] passive natural / natural passive ;
Write your answer and get it marked
On Oracle Prep you can write or photograph your own answer and have it marked by AI against this mark scheme, with feedback on what you missed.
Sign up free →