Golden orb weaver spiders, Nephila pilipes, are found in East Asia, South-east Asia and Australia. They are active in the day and at night. Golden orb weaver spiders build webs in trees and shrubs to catch different species of insects for food. All female golden orb weaver spiders are black with yellow spots on their legs and body. Biologists think that this adaptation evolved due to natural selection. Spiders with yellow spots may be able to attract more insects to their webs. Fig. 2.1 shows a female golden orb weaver spider sitting on a web. [Figure 2.1] Some biologists visited a forest in East Asia in July 2008. The biologists found five webs that were approximately the same size. Each web belonged to a female golden orb weaver spider. The biologists decided to investigate how the colour and pattern of spots on the spiders affect the number of insects attracted per hour to each web (insect attraction rate). The biologists made two-dimensional (2D) models of spiders, as shown in Table 2.1. [Table 2.1] At the first web, the biologists: • removed the living golden orb weaver spider from the web • placed model A in the centre of the web • placed a video camera 1 m from the web • filmed the web and model for 6 hours • recorded an insect attraction event whenever an insect flew towards the model, touched the model, or touched the web • calculated the insect attraction rate of model A. The procedure was repeated by placing models B, C, D and E on the four other webs. The whole investigation was repeated 25 times, and a mean insect attraction rate for each model was calculated.
- (a)(i)Identify the dependent variable in this investigation.[1]
- (a)(ii)The pattern of spots on models A and B was the same as the pattern of spots on female golden orb weaver spiders. Identify two other variables that the biologists should standardise when making the models for this investigation.[2]
- (a)(iii)Suggest a suitable control for this investigation.[1]
- (b)(i)Fig. 2.2 shows the mean insect attraction rates for the five models. The error bars show ± one standard error (SE). [Figure 2.2] Use the information shown in Table 2.1 and Fig. 2.2 to discuss the conclusions that can be made about the effect of colour and pattern of spots on the models on insect attraction rates.[4]
- (b)(ii)The biologists decided to analyse the data in Fig. 2.2 using t-tests. State a null hypothesis the biologists could make before carrying out the t-tests.[1]
- (b)(iii)State two reasons why the t-test is suitable for analysing the data shown in Fig. 2.2.[2]
- (c)A student thought that the investigation did not provide enough information about how the colour and pattern of spots on female golden orb weaver spiders help to attract insects to their webs. Suggest how this investigation could be improved to increase confidence in the results.[2]
This question uses a diagram from the original paper, which isn't shown here. Open the full paper from the past papers archive to see it.
Mark scheme
Marking points from the official mark scheme (May/June 2025). The mark or mark type is shown in brackets.
- [1] number of insect attraction events (in 6 hours);
- [1] size / length / AW (of model / body / legs);
- [1] shape / AW (of model);
- [1] material / AW (of models);
- [1] thickness / weight / mass / density / AW (of models) ;
- [1] yellow, colour / shade / tone / pigment / AW (of models) ;
- [1] light, absorption / reflection / AW (of models)
- [1] size of spots (on model A and B);
- [1] (models are) odourless / AW ;
- [1] (measure insect attraction rate of) web with no model ;
- [1] idea that yellow colour (models A, C and D), have high insect attraction rates ;
- [1] idea that pattern (of spots) is less important than colour (for attracting insects); ora
- [1] idea that, (standard) error bars for yellow (colour, models A, C, D) and not yellow (colour, models B, E), do not overlap, (therefore insect attraction rate may be) significantly different ;
- [1] idea that, (standard) error bars for models A, C, and D overlap, (therefore insect attraction rate) is not significantly different (for yellow models with different patterns);
- [1] or idea that, (standard) error bars for models B, and E overlap, therefore insect attraction rate is not significantly different (for black models with no yellow colour);
- [1] data quote, with units, to support;
- [1] there is no difference between, the (mean) insect attraction rates, of the models ;
- [1] data is continuous;
- [1] comparing (two) means ;
- [1] fewer than 30 values;
- [1] data is (from populations that are) normally distributed ;
- [1] do investigation in, more than one, forest / geographical area / AW ;
- [1] idea of do investigation, at different times of the day / AW ;
- [1] do investigation in, more than one, month / season / year;
- [1] idea that only count insects that touch the, model / web ;
- [1] use (more) models with different, colours / patterns or use 3-dimensional model (instead of, flat / 2-dimensional, model);
- [1] idea of (video) living spider on web ;
Write your answer and get it marked
On Oracle Prep you can write or photograph your own answer and have it marked by AI against this mark scheme, with feedback on what you missed.
Sign up free →