The responses of plant species to water stress can be classified as either isohydric or anisohydric. • Isohydric plant species close stomata during times of water stress. This behaviour minimises water loss by transpiration but also reduces carbon dioxide uptake for photosynthesis. • Anisohydric plant species do not close stomata during times of water stress. This behaviour maximises carbon dioxide uptake for photosynthesis but also increases water loss by transpiration. A biologist studied 10 tree species from Australia. The biologist studied the effect of water stress and high environmental temperatures on five isohydric tree species and five anisohydric tree species. For each tree species studied: • The biologist obtained 20 young trees. • The young trees were grown in containers of soil in controlled conditions in a glasshouse. • The environmental conditions in the glasshouse were chosen to represent summer conditions in Australia. The mean glasshouse temperature was 28°C. • All the young trees were given a good supply of water for 10 weeks, so that the young trees acclimatised to the environmental conditions in the glasshouse. After the 10-week period of acclimatisation, the biologist divided the young trees from each species into four groups of five trees. Table 2.1 shows the experimental conditions used by the biologist for the next five weeks. [Table 2.1] At the end of week 5, the biologist measured the stomatal conductance of three leaves from each young tree at 12:00 (midday). Stomatal conductance is a measure of water vapour loss from the intercellular air spaces of leaves to the atmosphere through the stomata.
- (a)State three environmental conditions in the glasshouse that should be standardised in the 10-week period of acclimatisation, other than the temperature of the glasshouse.[3]
- (b)Using Fig. 2.1, state the effect of a high mean temperature on the mean stomatal conductance of young trees that were given a good supply of water.[1]
- (c)With reference to Fig. 2.1 and Table 2.2, suggest and explain the conclusions that can be made about the effect of water stress and a high environmental temperature on isohydric and anisohydric tree species.[4]
- (d)(i)The biologist then analysed these data using a t-test to compare the mean percentage of leaves that were dead on the young trees of the isohydric and anisohydric species. State a null hypothesis for the t-test.[1]
- (d)(ii)The formula for the t-test is: t = (x̄₁ - x̄₂) / √((s₁²/n₁) + (s₂²/n₂)) key to symbols: x̄ = mean s = sample standard deviation n = sample size (number of observations) The biologist calculated √((s₁²/n₁) + (s₂²/n₂)) = 8.231 Use this value and Table 2.3 to calculate the value of t for these data. Show your working.[2]
- (d)(iii)The degrees of freedom for this t-test are 48. Table 2.4 shows the probability table for the t-test. [Table 2.4] Using Table 2.4 and the calculated value of t from (d)(ii), describe what the biologist can conclude from the results shown in Table 2.3.[3]
This question uses a diagram from the original paper, which isn't shown here. Open the full paper from the past papers archive to see it.
Mark scheme
Marking points from the official mark scheme (May/June 2024). The mark or mark type is shown in brackets.
- [1] light intensity ;
- [1] duration / hours / AW, of light ;
- [1] volume, of water (added to soil) ;
- [1] type/pH, of soil;
- [1] mineral (ion), concentration (in soil) ;
- [1] humidity;
- [1] carbon dioxide concentration;
- [1] (high mean temperature leads to) lower / AW (mean stomatal conductance), in both isohydric and anisohydric (species) ; ora
- [1] conclusion: (water stress leads to) lower / AW, (mean stomatal) conductance in isohydric and anisohydric (species) ; ora
- [1] explanation: idea that (lower stomatal conductance when exposed to water stress indicates that) water loss (by transpiration) is reduced;
- [1] conclusion: isohydric (species exposed to water stress and a high temperature) increase (mean stomatal) conductance or increased (mean stomatal) conductance for isohydric (species exposed to water stress and a high temperature) is (statistically) significant ;
- [1] explanation: idea that (increased mean stomatal conductance in isohydric species exposed to water stress and a high temperature) has a cooling effect ;
- [1] conclusion: anisohydric (species exposed to water stress and a high temperature) do not change (mean stomatal) conductance or change / difference / decrease / AW, in (mean stomatal) conductance for anisohydric (species exposed to water stress and a high temperature) is not (statistically) significant ;
- [1] explanation: idea that (unchanged mean stomatal conductance in anisohydric species when exposed to water stress and a high temperature) to allow carbon dioxide uptake (for photosynthesis);
- [1] conclusion: paired data quote to support conclusion;
- [1] idea that there is no difference between the (mean) percentage of leaves that were dead on (young trees from) isohydric species and (young trees from) anisohydric species ;
- [1] 1.883;
- [1] t = (19.0 - 3.5) / 8.231;
- [1] calculated value of, t / 1.883, is less than, 2.011 / critical value (at p = 0.05) or calculated value of, t / 1.883, is less than, 2.682 / critical value (at p = 0.01); ora
- [1] null hypothesis is accepted (at p = 0.05 / p = 0.01);
- [1] there is no significant difference (at p = 0.05 / p = 0.01);
Write your answer and get it marked
On Oracle Prep you can write or photograph your own answer and have it marked by AI against this mark scheme, with feedback on what you missed.
Sign up free →